MLB The Show 13 Gameplay Video - Atlanta Braves vs. Washington Nationals (Postseason)

[PsychoBulk]

Re: MLB 13 The Show gameplay video

I think if truth be told, its hard to get commentary in ANY sports game to not sound repetitive pretty quickly, its the nature of the beast with limited disk space etc, but even as a Show lover i can see where the commentary on this game could do with some love, but im sure next year with the PS4 we will get it.

To me it doesnt impact the enjoyment i get from the game in any way.

[etched Chaos]

Re: MLB 13 The Show gameplay video

I think if truth be told, its hard to get commentary in ANY sports game to not sound repetitive pretty quickly, its the nature of the beast with limited disk space etc, but even as a Show lover i can see where the commentary on this game could do with some love, but im sure next year with the PS4 we will get it.

To me it doesnt impact the enjoyment i get from the game in any way.

Yea, I still play 3-4 RTTS players with over 10 years under each player's belt, and the commentary has never stopped me from enjoying every moment. But, it doesn't make it any less glaring as a weakness.

[ManiacMatt1782]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Gameplay Video - Atlanta Braves vs. Washington Nationals (Postsea

Wtf? ABSOLUTELY no emotion from Matt V when Harper in that homerun? Come on........

He was doing a Joe Buck impression when anyone but the Cards play. Seriously real life baseball announcers are generally emotionless except for a few. Someone brought up Thorne. Thorne is/ was a hockey announcer. He is used to fast paced excited calling from the nature of hockey. I honestly don't think Matty V is really all that bad, especially in comparison to Fox's real life number 1 broadcaster who may me the most dry mundane unexcited commentator in the history of sports.

[ScouserHUN]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Gameplay Video - Atlanta Braves vs. Washington Nationals (Postsea

He was doing a Joe Buck impression when anyone but the Cards play. Seriously real life baseball announcers are generally emotionless except for a few. Someone brought up Thorne. Thorne is/ was a hockey announcer. He is used to fast paced excited calling from the nature of hockey. I honestly don't think Matty V is really all that bad, especially in comparison to Fox's real life number 1 broadcaster who may me the most dry mundane unexcited commentator in the history of sports.

Vin Scully for the Show!

[kbusch22]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Gameplay Video - Atlanta Braves vs. Washington Nationals (Postsea

I was actually hoping they were going to show the players from the starting lineups getting introduced and running out individually. Not just a 2 second clip of one guy slapping high fives from the rest of the roster before they move on to the next scene.

[Armor and Sword]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Gameplay Video - Atlanta Braves vs. Washington Nationals (Postsea

The Commentary on The Show is decent. I think it is so beat to death though all ready.

I feel relaxed as well as focused at the same time when playing the game and I am glad it is not over he top for the most part. I have played well over a 1000 games between 2009-present. In the grand scheme it has not hindered my pure love and joy for this game.

Yes 2K Basketball is the gold standard. No question.

I even think 2K baseball has great play by play. But it is not that much better (2K baseball not Basketball). Better yes....but not worlds better IMO. Dare I say too much chatter? And in baseball....IMO it is not needed. All depends how you like to enjoy the sport. I am too focused on placing my pitches, checking the match ups, at bat getting focused and looking for certain pitches....most of the time the play by play an color comes in right when it should....after the hit, after the pitch and it does a decent job. Sometimes I hear things I never heard before each year I play the game. They do add new lines every year.

Can it be better....absolutely. Is it keeping this game from being the best console sports game on the planet?

Oh come on now......hell freaking no.

And this is a home video.....I turned it off right after the pre-game intros (which were pretty awesome). Nice touch with post-season mode so far!!!

Can't wait till next week!!!

[Drew127]

And buried in this thread are tidbits of people pointing out issues with stuttering which would have mucho the far reaching implications on the enjoyment of this game...yet no one seems to want to talk about that. And how about the impressions I have heard about how easy it is to hit because there are much more meat balls thrown?

These are topics worth discussing but this thread is commentary bashing and nothing else which is frustrating.

[macavity]

For me, great commentary gives a game heart and soul and that emotional element translates to playability and old fashioned fun. Based on what I've heard in this video, I'll be skipping The Show this year and sticking with MLB2K13, for all its undoubted flaws. Maybe I'm in the minority but I prefer quirky company with something interesting to say more than that of beautiful people with no conversation!

[MrOldboy]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Gameplay Video - Atlanta Braves vs. Washington Nationals (Postsea

And buried in this thread are tidbits of people pointing out issues with stuttering which would have mucho the far reaching implications on the enjoyment of this game...yet no one seems to want to talk about that. And how about the impressions I have heard about how easy it is to hit because there are much more meat balls thrown?

These are topics worth discussing but this thread is commentary bashing and nothing else which is frustrating.

They are there. A few early ones I noticed. I'll have to watch the gameplay closely to see if it happens then. But I didn't find these jarring or anything, granted it was shot off a camera so I'm sure it'll be more noticeable on a TV in front of your eyes perhaps.

http://youtu.be/GQrqOMQU88M?t=1m15s

http://youtu.be/GQrqOMQU88M?t=2m10s

http://youtu.be/GQrqOMQU88M?t=2m42s

edit: Sorry had to point it out as rewatching the video I heard it like 5 times. Honestly though this might be the most authentic piece of commentary in the game. How many times have you been pissed off at an announcer calling a pitch wrong? I know I have.

http://youtu.be/GQrqOMQU88M?t=4m10s

[Cavicchi]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Gameplay Video - Atlanta Braves vs. Washington Nationals (Postsea

I don't have an issue with the commentary at all...I sounds real and authentic..I mean really, go listen to a real broadest, sounds dead almost all the time until someone makes a big play anyway..

This isn't football or basketball.

Check out Vin Scully.

[royals852]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Gameplay Video - Atlanta Braves vs. Washington Nationals (Postsea

They are there. A few early ones I noticed. I'll have to watch the gameplay closely to see if it happens then. But I didn't find these jarring or anything, granted it was shot off a camera so I'm sure it'll be more noticeable on a TV in front of your eyes perhaps.

http://youtu.be/GQrqOMQU88M?t=1m15s

http://youtu.be/GQrqOMQU88M?t=2m10s

http://youtu.be/GQrqOMQU88M?t=2m42s

edit: Sorry had to point it out as rewatching the video I heard it like 5 times. Honestly though this might be the most authentic piece of commentary in the game. How many times have you been pissed off at an announcer calling a pitch wrong? I know I have.

http://youtu.be/GQrqOMQU88M?t=4m10s

What exactly do you mean the announcer calling the pitch wrong? They say " 1-2 is an off speed pitch. No dice its 2-2." The pitch was a change up which is an off speed pitch. The other then goes on to say "All hard stuff here to get ahead. But now the're trying to get him out with breaking ball and he's not falling for it." The pitch again was a change up which does break. Now 2 of the first 3 pitches prior were fastballs and 1 change up. So that is wrong.

[MrOldboy]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Gameplay Video - Atlanta Braves vs. Washington Nationals (Postsea

What exactly do you mean the announcer calling the pitch wrong? They say " 1-2 is an off speed pitch. No dice its 2-2." The pitch was a change up which is an off speed pitch. The other then goes on to say "All hard stuff here to get ahead. But now the're trying to get him out with breaking ball and he's not falling for it." The pitch again was a change up which does break. Now 2 of the first 3 pitches prior were fastballs and 1 change up. So that is wrong.

A changeup is not a breaking ball. At least I've never heard it be referred as one. If a CH is considered a breaking ball then yeah there is nothing with that commentary.

But I always thought there were distinct categories of pitches.

Fastballs (2-seam, sinker, etc) , Changeups (circle CH, palmball, etc) and Breaking balls (curveball, slider, etc).

[nemesis04]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Gameplay Video - Atlanta Braves vs. Washington Nationals (Postsea

Check out Vin Scully.

I thought he was horrible when he did the commentary for this series. Talk about boring! As far as the commentary we all know it needs a new direction and approach. It's not the best but it also is not the worst. It is actually pretty deep in content but falls short on approach and style. SCEA is aware of what people are looking for but I would not expect the transformation to happen on the turn of a dime.

As far as the stutter hang ups, I saw a few of them in that vid. Curious if he did the min or max install. Also, before anyone asks we don't play the game off a disk so we would not pick that up at CD.

[MrOldboy]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Gameplay Video - Atlanta Braves vs. Washington Nationals (Postsea

As far as the stutter hang ups, I saw a few of them in that vid. Curious if he did the min or max install. Also, before anyone asks we don't play the game off a disk so we would not pick that up at CD.

So would you think the stutters are only due to the game accessing data off of the disc?

Maybe the stuttering might be a reason for people to get the game off of PSN instead.

[nemesis04]

Re: MLB The Show 13 Gameplay Video - Atlanta Braves vs. Washington Nationals (Postsea

So would you think the stutters are only due to the game accessing data off of the disc?

Maybe the stuttering might be a reason for people to get the game off of PSN instead.

It is possible, it will be interesting to see if the people who do the digital download experience it or not.