NCAA Football 14 - A Deeper Look at Power Recruiting

[jello1717]

Re: NCAA Football 14 - A Deeper Look at Power Recruiting

I believe that pitch is based on the ratings of the guys at that position on your depth chart (excluding seniors), and the ratings of other players at that position on your recruit board. So what were the ratings of these guys in your example compared to your depth chart and recruit board?

This.

It's also combined requirements based on your playbook. IE. these are the 4-3, multiple, and 3-4 requirements.

[jello1717]

Re: NCAA Football 14 - A Deeper Look at Power Recruiting

Two things I'd like to see, having not yet read the article:
2. Quicker recruiting in general. I don't like having the CPU totally in charge of recruiting, but at the same time, it often takes forever to recruit, to the point where it gets boring for me and the others in my dynasty.

You really need to read the article.

[BleedGreen710]

Re: NCAA Football 14 - A Deeper Look at Power Recruiting

I don't get why only QBs, FB, HB, WR,TE, and Safeties can have 'competitive visits'. If I bring in 3 cornerbacks or 3 linebackers how is that going to have a different effect as bringing in 3 WRs? Great example of EA Sports having a great idea but executing it poorly.

[The JareBear]

Re: NCAA Football 14 - A Deeper Look at Power Recruiting

I don't get why only QBs, FB, HB, WR,TE, and Safeties can have 'competitive visits'. If I bring in 3 cornerbacks or 3 linebackers how is that going to have a different effect as bringing in 3 WRs? Great example of EA Sports having a great idea but executing it poorly.

Pretty par for the course for this gen.

[Greekcian]

Re: NCAA Football 14 - A Deeper Look at Power Recruiting

So I can't let three recievers visit at the same time even if i'm running the one-back or they'll become rivals but I can bring in 6 tackles and they'll all be best buddies? Now that doesn't make any sense or does it?

[mailman2]

Re: NCAA Football 14 - A Deeper Look at Power Recruiting

So I can't let three recievers visit at the same time even if i'm running the one-back or they'll become rivals but I can bring in 6 tackles and they'll all be best buddies? Now that doesn't make any sense or does it?

If you have 6 new tackles I'm pretty sure they all be playing together tho, just saying.

[TarHeelPhenom]

Re: NCAA Football 14 - A Deeper Look at Power Recruiting

Khalid is right...if a school's pitch ratings are too high in the game then we would be able to go in and change it. Louisville would be a great example of a good program with a low education grade. Stanford would be A+

[Colorado Cooler]

Re: NCAA Football 14 - A Deeper Look at Power Recruiting

As of June 5th, the top 30 college teams in the national recruiting rankings already have an average of 10 commitments on board. Most of these prospects didn't wait for the last visit nor did they care about competitive visits. I applaud EA for incorporating some new concepts, but if they make them bigger than what they really are, we're taking two-steps forward and one back. Many prospects in college football go off the board early and we need to have that in this game if realism is a goal.

[fcboiler87]

Re: NCAA Football 14 - A Deeper Look at Power Recruiting

As of June 5th, the top 30 college teams in the national recruiting rankings already have an average of 10 commitments on board. Most of these prospects didn't wait for the last visit nor did they care about competitive visits. I applaud EA for incorporating some new concepts, but if they make them bigger than what they really are, we're taking two-steps forward and one back. Many prospects in college football go off the board early and we need to have that in this game if realism is a goal.

I agree completely. That is why I think we should have a 5 week recruiting session before the season kind of like they had post season in years past. Teams like Texas and Michigan are already almost done with their classes. This 5 week session would allow you to do a good deal of scouting, offer top prospects and get an idea of who is realistic to go after through the season. This isn't entirely realistic but it's the best thing I can think of to emulate the long off season where a lot of recruiting takes place.

[TheDelta]

Re: NCAA Football 14 - A Deeper Look at Power Recruiting

As of June 5th, the top 30 college teams in the national recruiting rankings already have an average of 10 commitments on board. Most of these prospects didn't wait for the last visit nor did they care about competitive visits. I applaud EA for incorporating some new concepts, but if they make them bigger than what they really are, we're taking two-steps forward and one back. Many prospects in college football go off the board early and we need to have that in this game if realism is a goal.

You make it sound like waiting until the very last moment would be the only way to ever gain commitments in 14, nothing they said so far implied that from what I heard, they still got insta-commits so I'd say it should still be possible to lock up a few players early, some over the course of the season and the rest, including many high-profile prospects that get chased by a lot of schools, drag it out until signing day, doesn't sound so far off to me.

[BleedGreen710]

Re: NCAA Football 14 - A Deeper Look at Power Recruiting

You make it sound like waiting until the very last moment would be the only way to ever gain commitments in 14, nothing they said so far implied that from what I heard, they still got insta-commits so I'd say it should still be possible to lock up a few players early, some over the course of the season and the rest, including many high-profile prospects that get chased by a lot of schools, drag it out until signing day, doesn't sound so far off to me.

yeah exactly and theres even a coach skill which when maxed gives 25% chance of insta-commit when offering scholarships to players who have you ranked #1

[mattbooty]

My thoughts on the bonus for late visits.... One thing to keep in mind, when comparing it to "real life", if a kid goes on his first visit and commits, he still has the option to decommit and choose another school, and often that happens. A kid will commit early (often times just to get the recruiters off their back during their final season), then take a few more visits and possibly change his commitment. Since NCAA is (unfortunately) a single commit and they are done, we have to keep that in perspective... many times you will hear recruiting "experts" (admittedly may not be as knowledgeable as they claim) say that team X has a chance at nabbing a kid because they are his last visit before making his decision. That doesn't mean its a definite, but its widely considered to be a bonus...

Look at Jabrill Peppers... he was considered a Michigan lock most of the year, then leading up to his decision he scheduled PSU as his final visit and although he did end up sticking with Michigan, most people thought PSU at least had a chance because their visit would be freshest in his mind when he made his decision.

So I do think adding some value to being the final visit is legit. Now if it turns out the way it is programmed getting the final visit is some sort of "cheat code" to locking in any recruit you want, then its poorly done. But just giving you a relatively small boost i think is valid.

[Strategizer]

Re: NCAA Football 14 - A Deeper Look at Power Recruiting

You make it sound like waiting until the very last moment would be the only way to ever gain commitments in 14, nothing they said so far implied that from what I heard, they still got insta-commits so I'd say it should still be possible to lock up a few players early, some over the course of the season and the rest, including many high-profile prospects that get chased by a lot of schools, drag it out until signing day, doesn't sound so far off to me.

Yes, exactly. His point didn't really make sense because guys will still commit before they take all or any of their visits. The devs have said this is one of the risks of scheduling that visit as late as possible. Also the new lockout feature could come into play if you wait too long to schedule a visit and you fall too far behind other schools.

I also don't understand how he knows all of these early commits didn't care about competitive visits. Did he read interviews with all of them saying they didn't care to be visiting with multiple recruits at the same position? Seems unlikely.

I can understand being a little wary of how new additions to the game will work, but if you are going to compare them to a real world situation to express your concern, the comparison needs to make sense. That said, I would like the idea of a set period of "preseason" recruiting where you can begin scouting and recruiting players before the season actually starts. I think that paired with a decommit system would be a great way to build on the changes and additions EA made this year.

[Colorado Cooler]

Re: NCAA Football 14 - A Deeper Look at Power Recruiting

Yes, exactly. His point didn't really make sense because guys will still commit before they take all or any of their visits. The devs have said this is one of the risks of scheduling that visit as late as possible. Also the new lockout feature could come into play if you wait too long to schedule a visit and you fall too far behind other schools.

I also don't understand how he knows all of these early commits didn't care about competitive visits. Did he read interviews with all of them saying they didn't care to be visiting with multiple recruits at the same position? Seems unlikely.

I can understand being a little wary of how new additions to the game will work, but if you are going to compare them to a real world situation to express your concern, the comparison needs to make sense. That said, I would like the idea of a set period of "preseason" recruiting where you can begin scouting and recruiting players before the season actually starts. I think that paired with a decommit system would be a great way to build on the changes and additions EA made this year.

I made the comment about recruits not caring about competitive visits because these players committed before their respective schools have even built their 2014 visit lists (per Rivals data bases). They will take their officials later. Thus, competitive visits were not a factor in their decisions. I do not dismiss the significance of competitive visits or the last visit as long as they're kept in perspective. My main point here as reiterated by fcboiler is commitment lists fill up much faster in real life as in this game, and if realism is a goal, that needs to change. In years past, many top 3 and 4 star recruits in the game lasted into the middle of the season without an offer. Anything EA can do to close the gap between their game concept and reality, I'm all for.

[Strategizer]

Re: NCAA Football 14 - A Deeper Look at Power Recruiting

I made the comment about recruits not caring about competitive visits because these players committed before their respective schools have even built their 2014 visit lists (per Rivals data bases). They will take their officials later. Thus, competitive visits were not a factor in their decisions. I do not dismiss the significance of competitive visits or the last visit as long as they're kept in perspective. My main point here as reiterated by fcboiler is commitment lists fill up much faster in real life as in this game, and if realism is a goal, that needs to change. In years past, many top 3 and 4 star recruits in the game lasted into the middle of the season without an offer. Anything EA can do to close the gap between their game concept and reality, I'm all for.

I think you mean complimentary visits, as the competitive visit is what you don't want. And I don't see how that is any different than your point about late visits - if a recruit in '14 commits without a complimentary visit, which is obviously possible, then it wasn't a factor. So what do these real life recruits have to do with those new aspects of visits in the game?

I think your point about all the early commits would make more sense if you were arguing for a preseason recruiting period like fcboiler was. I just don't think it says anything about the new visit features, which do take into account early commits.