Share Your Madden NFL 25 Rosters, Sliders, and Custom Playbooks with Madden Share

[HeavyHitter55]

Re: Share Your Madden NFL 25 Rosters, Sliders, and Custom Playbooks with Madden Share

The Gameplanning/Strategy and Sliders forums are going to blow up now...

That's for sure.

I'm, honestly, really excited about this - after some time, and some collaboration (similar to the collaborative efforts in naming every NCAA player) this could turn the game into something that keeps people interested for a while. Especially those who play against the CPU, and/or control all 32 teams in Franchise mode.

If the community plays this new share feature right, the results could be huge.

This may have just convinced me to buy...

[crf2013]

Re: Share Your Madden NFL 25 Rosters, Sliders, and Custom Playbooks with Madden Share

[QUOTE=azdawgpound;2045161652]u can share created rosters that have complete draft classes of well over 300+ so I don't see why u wouldn't be able to share the draft classes from ncaa esp if u can import them from ncaa to madden.
importing a ton of pre created guys and building a ton of new guys are 2 different things and those are rosters not draft classes ncaa has those in there game so its still a big FU to them to add their own draft class maker

[gr18]

Re: Share Your Madden NFL 25 Rosters, Sliders, and Custom Playbooks with Madden Share

One of my biggest worries about the game is the difficulty in getting fairly accurate draft classes so this would be the feature that I would find most useful.That being said,this would make some people skip NCAA if you could easily do this.I may still buy it because I enjoy the demo but I can see possibly having headaches with generating decent draft classes from NCAA that would make you feel like using Madden's.

[auburnfan2]

Don't know about custom playbooks but sliders and rosters is definitely a plus

Sent from my SCH-R530M using Tapatalk 4 Beta

[RogueHominid]

Re: Share Your Madden NFL 25 Rosters, Sliders, and Custom Playbooks with Madden Share

This is definitely an awesome feature. There are great roster makers for NCAA football and The Show. Bringing the ability to edit rosters for sim style players here on OS is huge. I know I'll use that feature.

The playbook sharing is also huge in my opinion. Guys who watch a lot of tape on their favorite team can weigh in on how often certain plays are used, which ones aren't in the book, etc. Creating custom playbooks for your team--IN FRANCHISE!!!--is a monster feature.

I really like the idea of being able to custom mold a playbook that takes advantage of MY roster, rather than having to rely on a preset PB from another team. With OAK, I'm for sure going to keep some deep stuff and PA stuff, but I'm going to add more WC concepts for Flynn. As it stands OAK's PB is set up for DMC and a deep thrower, but not for DMC and a short to intermediate guy like Flynn. Control over the content of my playbook is a great addition.

[carnalnirvana]

Re: Share Your Madden NFL 25 Rosters, Sliders, and Custom Playbooks with Madden Share

I REALLY HOPE the offline users can somehow get playbooks to either coaches or teams to fix the cpu...

i am not getting my hopes up because getting a so close is worse than actually not having anything at all imo.... in terms of customization for the cpu

[goravens2052]

Re: Share Your Madden NFL 25 Rosters, Sliders, and Custom Playbooks with Madden Share

This sounds great. Sounds like EA finally caught up to all the other websites that allow you to share rosters and other things. Just wish Draft Classes were allowed but maybe one day they can allow us to make Customized Draft Classes that can be downloaded through Madden Share.

[jerwoods]

Re: Share Your Madden NFL 25 Rosters, Sliders, and Custom Playbooks with Madden Share

this is huge i can finally share my spaced out rosters ratings wise with everyone

hopefully i can be the Bed19 of madden

i think u can create 300-400 guys and with the ncaa import back u can create draft guys as well


my psn is FunTimes72 look for my rosters sadly once i get the game it will take about a month to fix the overrated rosters i will try to update every 4 weeks

[gr18]

Re: Share Your Madden NFL 25 Rosters, Sliders, and Custom Playbooks with Madden Share

this is huge i can finally share my spaced out rosters ratings wise with everyone

hopefully i can be the Bed19 of madden

i think u can create 300-400 guys and with the ncaa import back u can create draft guys as well


my psn is FunTimes72 look for my rosters sadly once i get the game it will take about a month to fix the overrated rosters i will try to update every 4 weeks

While I like the idea of ratings a little more spread out you have to take into account that you don't want 7th round draft picks rated like low end starters and 3rd rounders practically all-pros.These concepts worked with Madden 10 when ratings were designed spread out or Madden 12 when you could edit in franchise.

[Big FN Deal]

Re: Share Your Madden NFL 25 Rosters, Sliders, and Custom Playbooks with Madden Share

Well I guess FBG ratings this year it is!

Mmmm.... this would be really hard to pull off in CFM.... if you use FBG ratings that would only mean that most of the incoming rookies from pre-made draft classes would be beasts straight away and eventually dominate all starting positions, thus leaving the "realistic" rosters/ratings at a disadvantage.

this is huge i can finally share my spaced out rosters ratings wise with everyone

hopefully i can be the Bed19 of madden

i think u can create 300-400 guys and with the ncaa import back u can create draft guys as well


my psn is FunTimes72 look for my rosters sadly once i get the game it will take about a month to fix the overrated rosters i will try to update every 4 weeks

I put all these posts together to ask a question about what may be possible now with Madden share. Considering that NCAA football already has a share feature and the community edits rosters in that game, it should be possible to essentially create draft classes for import into Madden, right? I mean I don't know if NCAA football allows rosters to be edited every off season or only before starting a Dynasty but depending on how NCAA 14 player ratings are converted when importing to Madden 25, it may be possible to have at least 4-5 years(including Redshirts) of created draft classes from NCAA to import into Madden.

Hopefully someone(s) understand what I am getting at and can help me understand if this will likely be possible of not.

I personally would rather use FBG ratings in Madden but the fact that generated draft classes would come in and taint the pool always detoured me. Now if it's possible to to essentially create custom draft classes by editing players in NCAA, there could at least be a could 4-5 draft classes scaled back to better fit with FBG rated players in Madden.

[gr18]

Re: Share Your Madden NFL 25 Rosters, Sliders, and Custom Playbooks with Madden Share

I put all these posts together to ask a question about what may be possible now with Madden share. Considering that NCAA football already has a share feature and the community edits rosters in that game, it should be possible to essentially create draft classes for import into Madden, right? I mean I don't know if NCAA football allows rosters to be edited every off season or only before starting a Dynasty but depending on how NCAA 14 player ratings are converted when importing to Madden 25, it may be possible to have at least 4-5 years(including Redshirts) of created draft classes from NCAA to import into Madden.

Hopefully someone(s) understand what I am getting at and can help me understand if this will likely be possible of not.
I personally would rather use FBG ratings in Madden but the fact that generated draft classes would come in and taint the pool always detoured me. Now if it's possible to to essentially create custom draft classes by editing players in NCAA, there could at least be a could 4-5 draft classes scaled back to better fit with FBG rated players in Madden.

I'm hoping it's like what you're alluding to but I'm betting it's tied into you at least having the NCAA game and either doing it yourself or getting a draft class from someone through NCAA share and then importing.

[Big FN Deal]

Re: Share Your Madden NFL 25 Rosters, Sliders, and Custom Playbooks with Madden Share

I'm hoping it's like what you're alluding to but I'm betting it's tied into you at least having the NCAA game and either doing it yourself or getting a draft class from someone through NCAA share and then importing.

That's what I am banking or hoping on, that the people in the community that work so hard on edits to NCAA can put out better scaled draft classes. I just want some rosters based on actual data and not some made up stuff. It will likely all come down to how the NCAA draft classes are converted into Madden but I was just reading about the Dynasty editor for NCAA football, so it will be interesting to see what all shakes out in reference to draft imports and M25 once the games drop.

[schmit_95]

Re: Share Your Madden NFL 25 Rosters, Sliders, and Custom Playbooks with Madden Share

This sounds great for the people out there that love this kind of thing. I on the other hand don't see any appeal to this. I get the roster stuff and wanting real names, that just sounds like a ton of work. Howver, the playbook thing I dont see at all. Save a handful of unique plays, arent every teams playbooks almost identical? Not feeling this revel at all....Im really REALLY hoping that the MAdden all 25 reveal is something that noone saw coming. It's really the only thing left that can get me over the hump....I realize no one else cares, but I needed to say it. Haha. Cheers to everyone that is pysched for this feature though!

[BizDevConglomerate]

This is a new Era ppl. Instead of asking questions that won't get answered. See what direction they are headed. This will hopefully be in all their games. I'm excited with EA. hopefully Donny Moore doesn't need to get replaced by the community.

What I will be skeptical about is the amount of editin that is in the game. Last year I had many twitter convo's with EA about the editing. When the added editing they left out ratings. I'm gettin it but I won't be totally satisfied if they leave that out. I want full control. And it looks like they're going in that direction.

💩

[infemous]

Re: Share Your Madden NFL 25 Rosters, Sliders, and Custom Playbooks with Madden Share

sounds promising.

i think there are some valid concerns about the whole notion of sharing cheesy rosters but that will be done regardless.

i think this can only be a good thing that will allow for people to share their rosters and improve the game.

i'm imagining an online CCM with slider sets, scaled down ratings and custom playbooks.... although only on PS4 lol