Hakeem Olajuwon Vs Shaquille O'Neal

[24]

There have been quite a few comparison threads popping up so I thought to throw this one out there. I would think the majority of Basketball fans here saw both of these players at their respective peaks. With that being said who would you rather have on your team?

Myself personally I have a tough time picking between the two. Shaq put together some of the best games I have ever seen in my entire life. Especially during his early finals runs with the Lakers. At The same time I can't get over how Hakeem would move down low. He had some of the best footwork I ever saw. Not to mention how great he was on the defensive end.

[JerzeyReign]

Re: Hakeem Olajuwon Vs Shaquille O'Neal

Shaq was pure force. Akeem was graceful. He used to pull back to the three point line and cross dudes up. He could score in so many ways.

Akeem could step on a court today and his footwork would allow him to dominate. This is a runaway in my mind but they are both great. Akeem tho... man he was super nice.

[AlexBrady]

Re: Hakeem Olajuwon Vs Shaquille O'Neal

Shaquille O'Neal would be the pick. He was one of the best ever at holding his spot in the low post and catching the entry pass. Now, the ball is four feet from the basket and the defense has to stretch into alignments that are totally unsound. Can't front him either because that would be self-defeating. Only McHale had a wider variety of moves in the low post. Shaq puts more pressure on the defense than Hakeem does.

Hakeem was a quick-stepping face the basket center. A finesse guy. He drop-stepped into his fadeaway. Sometimes he faked the drop step. He wasn't really a low poster in the mold of McHale or Shaq. Thats a myth. Better rebounder and defender than Shaq, although he was always in foul trouble.

[JerzeyReign]

Re: Hakeem Olajuwon Vs Shaquille O'Neal

Akeem wasn't a low post guy? Alright alright alright....

[dsallupinyaarea]

Re: Hakeem Olajuwon Vs Shaquille O'Neal

Are we picking primes or total careers?

If I'm getting a 3 year prime, I'm taking Shaq. I've just never seen a physical force like an in shape and motivated Shaq.

If I'm getting the whole career, I'm taking a Hakeem. Shaq left a lot on the table because he had outside interests. Not knocking him for it (basketball isn't everything), but it's just a fact.

[ojandpizza]

Hakeem had developed a skill set that separated him from any other bigman ever. He was long, athletic, and had so many go to moves it was a nightmare to defend. And he was a far better defensive player then Shaq was..

But sometimes when you have too much size and too much talent that's all that matters.. Shaq at his peak was probably the greatest center of all time. If he could have stretched out that peak to lost longer than 2-3 seasons he would be looked at as an ever greater player than he already is..

I think if you look at their career as a whole Hakeem would land higher on my all-time list than Shaq would.. But if you took the two of them at their very best and matched them against each other Shaq beats Hakeem.

[jeebs9]

Re: Hakeem Olajuwon Vs Shaquille O'Neal

It's like Jordan vs James to a point. One guys had the nasty skills for his game. And the other just a pure beast. Even though Shaq took the off season too seriously. (And ate too much.) I always felt he left at least 2 more rings in LA. We might not see anyone like him for a very long time.

[RedSceptile]

Re: Hakeem Olajuwon Vs Shaquille O'Neal

Olajuwon is onw of my favorite guys to ever play but Shaq is just a monster. I mean in his prime years the only guy that was stopping Shaq was well Shaq (and the free throw line).

[return.specialist]

Re: Hakeem Olajuwon Vs Shaquille O'Neal

Olajuwan. I love Shaq's game, and as a fan I prefered seeing O's game, but Shaq was amazing sight to behold because of his sheer dominance and power when he needed or wanted to be. As an owner I would take Shaq given his personality and antics were a huge draw but given the application of hindsight, as a GM I would take Hakeem because of his longevity and work ethic.

[Fiasco West]

Re: Hakeem Olajuwon Vs Shaquille O'Neal

Voted...I'm a bit biased though. Hakeem may just be the most skilled center to ever play the game though, played in a really tough era (Shaq did too but was the youngster at that time)

[BringTheHeat]

Re: Hakeem Olajuwon Vs Shaquille O'Neal

Shaq. Competes with Wilt for most dominating player of all time. Teams had to plan completely around trying to slow Shaq down.

Hakeem was more of a finesse player, and doesn't even have the best post moves of all time, yet he is always credited with such.

[ProfessaPackMan]

Re: Hakeem Olajuwon Vs Shaquille O'Neal

I'd love to hear your answer on who has better post moves than Hakeem as far as big men go? I definitely know he was one of the smartest players to play the game but his post game is/was legit and not something that is/was overhyped because of nostalgia. He's the only big men I've seen basically have his way with a prime, young Shaq.

And no jeebs, this is nothing like Lebron vs. Jordan man lol

[BringTheHeat]

Re: Hakeem Olajuwon Vs Shaquille O'Neal

I'd love to hear your answer on who has better post moves than Hakeem as far as big men go? I definitely know he was one of the smartest players to play the game but his post game is/was legit and not something that is/was overhyped because of nostalgia. He's the only big men I've seen basically have his way with a prime, young Shaq.

And no jeebs, this is nothing like Lebron vs. Jordan man lol

Kevin McHale.

<iframe width="420" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/wdtgUOiWHJg" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

[ProfessaPackMan]

Re: Hakeem Olajuwon Vs Shaquille O'Neal

I think it's a tossup between the two. I'd personally would go with Hakeem since I witnessed him play at his best and didn't with McHale(YouTube videos do nothing for me).

But you made it seem like Hakeem wasn't worthy of that claim and that's what I took issue with

[BringTheHeat]

Re: Hakeem Olajuwon Vs Shaquille O'Neal

I think it's a tossup between the two. I'd personally would go with Hakeem since I witnessed him play at his best and didn't with McHale(YouTube videos do nothing for me).

But you made it seem like Hakeem wasn't worthy of that claim and that's what I took issue with

Really it's a matter of what big man means, Centers-Hakeem by far. Big men meaning PF and C, I'll take McHale over Hakeem.

Both were amazing no doubt about it, and he deserves the praise for his footwork and craftiness.

Something I always notice about Hakeem, he makes quick moves, soon as he touches it he's gone, more people, guards and big men, need to do this!