[Kushmir]

+1 to accurate and consistent ratings.

Donnie Moore might be the #1 reason I dont play Madden anymore. Too many knee-jerk ratings based on silly stuff like one play/one big year or Jerome Simpson flipping over a guy for a TD and all of a sudden getting a 99 Jump rating...what? Rate what guys consistently do, not what they've done ONCE. The result good players too good and players rated less than 80 are horrible. Why use a 0-99 scale if only players rated 85+ can contribute?

Krisxsong, EA has the resources for a team like you mention but refuses to do it.

Ratings for active players should not exceed 96, and it should take consistently elite play to get a 90. AP isnt a 90 because he had a good couple of games, its because he gives you 1400+ yards every year an ACL doesn't stop him....and even when it does, he comes back and rushes for 2,000.