NCAA Will Not Renew EA Sports Contract, NCAA Football Series is Dead in Name Only -
Operation Sports Forums
If you're having problems logging in or staying logged in, please clear/delete your cookies/cache.
We are monitoring and fixing issues in this thread.
Thanks for your patience.
The upgrade is complete, but you've probably noticed the forums are only showing posts up to about April 8. Posts made after that are still in the process of being moved over, and that should take another week or two. Feel free to start a new thread.
The site might feel a little slow while work continues. Engineers are staying on it through the night to get things moving faster again. Thanks for your patience.
Re: NCAA Will Not Renew EA Sports Contract, NCAA Football Series is Dead in Name Only
I'll chalk this up as a win in my fantasy land... because now I can pretend that EA will bring back things such as taunting, and celebrating... and maybe even suspensions.
NOT KNOWING ANYTHING IS AWESOME, BECAUSE NOW I CAN MAKE STUFF UP!
--
Have you ever wanted to coach or play basketball at the next level, but something prevented you from achieving that dream? Fret no more. Ask me about SimWorld Hoops to see how you can create your virtual self, and follow your path from the prep-level to the pros.
Re: NCAA Will Not Renew EA Sports Contract, NCAA Football Series is Dead in Name Only
Originally posted by thinkjoey
there must be some restrictions that NCAA brought into the game
From what EA said...it was a mutual thing...so they must know the advantages of not having NCAA involved.
NCAA was a crutch in the beginning to convince people to buy the game...but now all they give are advertisements in the game...EA no longer needs them
Good step forward imo
I agree.....given the info in this thread I don't see EA needing the NCAA label to make a great college football game.
It would be great to see having to choose to suspend players who have violated team rules during your dynasty again (I'm pretty sure the NCAA played a part in getting this out of the game).
The only issue may be the future playoff system (I think the NCAA organizes the current BCS system....but I could be wrong) but that is an easy work-around. They can still have a 4 team playoff but just don't arrive at who makes it in the same way that the NCAA will figure it out.
I'm sure if you asked a lot of coaches/teams they would have plenty of negative things to say about how the NCAA goes about setting the rules. The Big 12 wants to have the option to have a conference championship game but they have to petition the NCAA to do it because of their rules. I'd imagine if you asked the head of the Big 12 he'd say it shouldn't be the NCAA's business on stuff like that and conferences should be able to make those decisions on their own.
Re: NCAA Will Not Renew EA Sports Contract, NCAA Football Series is Dead in Name Only
Originally posted by LastExit
I agree.....given the info in this thread I don't see EA needing the NCAA label to make a great college football game.
It would be great to see having to choose to suspend players who have violated team rules during your dynasty again (I'm pretty sure the NCAA played a part in getting this out of the game).
The only issue may be the future playoff system (I think the NCAA organizes the current BCS system....but I could be wrong) but that is an easy work-around. They can still have a 4 team playoff but just don't arrive at who makes it in the same way that the NCAA will figure it out.
I'm sure if you asked a lot of coaches/teams they would have plenty of negative things to say about how the NCAA goes about setting the rules. The Big 12 wants to have the option to have a conference championship game but they have to petition the NCAA to do it because of their rules. I'd imagine if you asked the head of the Big 12 he'd say it shouldn't be the NCAA's business on stuff like that and conferences should be able to make those decisions on their own.
Take a look at where their stock is right now compared to where it was before the recession (heck, even a few years ago). There's a number of issues as to why EA is losing money: lack of disposable income, lack of actually having a job, people moving into other gaming areas, etc... The industry as a whole is not doing really well right now.
I don't understand how they are hurting financially. They'll make tens of millions of dollars off Madden 25 in a few weeks. I understand there's a lot of costs involved, overhead, but the game industry as a whole is still doing quite well. See what Call of Duty did last year. Not under EA label, I know, but still ... in general, money being made. Sports games? Probably has taken a slide, but EA itself should be just fine.
It isn't really any more different to be honest, but with a major partner in the NCAA pulling out and with the lawsuits and EA tanking, I just don't see how this is just "business as usual." I know that if I'm one of the licensing companies or one of the individuals, I want to stay as far away from this lawsuit mess as possible. Not only that, but there's no guarentee that the prices are going to stay the same.
I know EA came out and said there would be a game next year. That's cute and all, but EA is hurting bad right now, and I don't think many people on here understand that. This is nothing but bad news for EA even though the NCAA isn't the all-in-all rights holder. It becomes a question for investors: "is EA doing the right thing by keeping this game afloat while the NCAA is ducking for cover?"
I understand people being "rah-rah!" and all, but you have to step back and look at the bigger picture. This is about more than a video game here.
One thing about EA and this series: Owen Goode said this is the 3rd largest selling sports game/franchise in the US. That's nothing to sneeze at and I can't see why stockholders would be so willing to give that up so easily.
NCAA: Michigan Wolverines
MLB: St. Louis Cardinals
NHL: St. Louis Blues
NFL: Pittsburgh Steelers
EPL: Liverpool Reds
Re: NCAA Will Not Renew EA Sports Contract, NCAA Football Series is Dead in Name Only
Originally posted by bigbob
I'll chalk this up as a win in my fantasy land... because now I can pretend that EA will bring back things such as taunting, and celebrating... and maybe even suspensions.
NOT KNOWING ANYTHING IS AWESOME, BECAUSE NOW I CAN MAKE STUFF UP!
The NCAA has gone way too far with how they define "taunting" these days so if one of the results of this is seeing some of what we've had in the past then I'd say this will be for the best. The suspensions thing would be a great thing to see put back in dynasty.
Here's a great example of how the NCAA has gone off the deep end in regards to "taunting" -
Re: NCAA Will Not Renew EA Sports Contract, NCAA Football Series is Dead in Name Only
Could getting rid of the NCAA license help?
*I would bet the NCAA were limiting playoff options in the game. I would love if they options more than just the 4 team coming. 8 team? 16 team? Old-school bowl only? I think 98 was the last to have options.
*Maybe player suspensions could get added? I don't want sanctions again but having X player suspended for a game would be cool. Especially if there was some warning that X player has been acting out/staying out late and you could fix it if you want. Again, I assume the NCAA that didn't love this.
*Wouldn't it be great if they gave up on trying to make accurate rosters and just let the community make the rosters themselves? Especially if they released the file early somehow as an excel file that we could work on before and then let you load the roster when the game is ready. I would be so excited for a true community roster that fans could build. It would be really good I bet.
Re: NCAA Will Not Renew EA Sports Contract, NCAA Football Series is Dead in Name Only
Originally posted by stlpimpmonsta
Cool people are answering my 1st question but what about the other question?
Why aren't the CLC being sued if they are the sole reason these games even exist?
The CLC isn't the reason the players aren't paid. The whole issue is over players not being eligible to receive compensation due to NCAA rules. I'm sure the CLC could care less if players are paid.
Tweet
Comment