So in my Michigan dynasty, Johnny Manziel won the Heisman in 2013, 2014, AND 2015. Every single year of his college career he won the Heisman (including 2012 in real life). I understand that he was rated 99 overall by year 2 of my dynasty and that he probably put up really good stats, but dont you think its a wee bit unrealistic for a guy to win 4 heisman trophies in 4 years? Nonetheless staying for all 4 years of your college career in this situation? Let me know what you guys think of this.
Heisman Trophy
Collapse
Recommended Videos
Collapse
X
-
Heisman Trophy
Not gonna call this a glitch, because it really isnt one, but its still kinda unrealistic.
So in my Michigan dynasty, Johnny Manziel won the Heisman in 2013, 2014, AND 2015. Every single year of his college career he won the Heisman (including 2012 in real life). I understand that he was rated 99 overall by year 2 of my dynasty and that he probably put up really good stats, but dont you think its a wee bit unrealistic for a guy to win 4 heisman trophies in 4 years? Nonetheless staying for all 4 years of your college career in this situation? Let me know what you guys think of this.Tigers|Wolverines|Red Wings|Pistons|LionsPSN - maizeblue13Tags: None -
Re: Heisman Trophy
Agreed I think that's a bit unrealistic. I don't know how often or if at all players in NCAA leave in their 3rd year if they're a star player, as they would do in real life. I wish it was a bit more realistic in that regard, but I haven't really tested it. I think that's weird though because he didn't win the heisman in either of the dynasty years i've played so far, and I didn't play them either time so he must have gotten hurt or had an off year haha -
Definitely seems like to many high rated juniors stay in school. 95+OVRPaul Harris...thats all
#9 Syracuse Orange!! (15-1)(3-0)Comment
-
Re: Heisman Trophy
Johnny Football won the Heisman in the first year of my dynasty and then the ND QB won in the second year. I agree it seems like some talented players stay but I haven't looked into it too much, I just know De'Anthony Thomas stayed and I think another marquee QB stayed.Comment
-
Re: Heisman Trophy
My main gripe about this is the fact that he won the heisman all four years of his college career, not that he stayed for his senior year after winning 3 heismansTigers|Wolverines|Red Wings|Pistons|LionsPSN - maizeblue13Comment
-
Re: Heisman Trophy
He robbed me as well! Ran for 2200+ plus yards and 37 TD's with Kent State's Dri Archer and Johnny Football still took home the Heisman.Comment
-
Re: Heisman Trophy
I think it has to do with OVR rating. The higher the players rating the more likely he is chosen.. that's the only logical explanation.Comment
-
Comment
-
Re: Heisman Trophy
That's a one off. He's never won it again in either of my dynasties (maybe once in a test dynasty). That's just random variance. The issue is that he didn't leave after his sophomore year. They need to tune the players leaving logic.Comment
-
-
Re: Heisman Trophy
Had the same problem in Road To Glory mode. My QB put up ridiculous stats in 2014 and took IU to the National Championship Game. Threw for 5,486 yards. 60 TDs against 12 INTs. 72.6%. Also ran for 1009 yards and 21 TDs. Still lost the Heisman to Manziel despite better stats and a better record. Set the NCAA record for passing TDs and still managed to run for 21 TDs. Crazy.Comment
-
Re: Heisman Trophy
I agree with that, the fact that he won 4 straight heismans is pure random luck but it is a problem that he stayed all 4 yearsTigers|Wolverines|Red Wings|Pistons|LionsPSN - maizeblue13Comment
Comment