This Player or That Player?

[HURRlSdel]

Delete............

[miz468]

Re: This Player or That Player?

This is a thread where you can ask the community questions about which specific player they would recommend.

Right now my HB is VT'S David Wilson and I'm looking to upgrade.

Who would you recommend between UGA's Heisman Winner Herschel Walker, Arkansas' Elite Darren McFadden, and Oklahoma's Gold Adrian Peterson? Why?

Feel free to respond to people's questions or pose your own this or that scenario.

Haven't played with Herschel, but I prefer DMC over AD because of his breakaway speed.

[iWaDe]

Re: This Player or That Player?

Sold my AP today for 20,000 and bought DM (elite) for 12'000, Big improvement so far and I like the switch but heard Walker breaks tackles like no other but in my opinion take DM

[thekicoach76]

Re: This Player or That Player?

I would highly recommend Elite Darren McFadden. He is a beast of a RB and you can get him pretty cheap around 18000 I have seen. Average is 20000 to 25000.

[TryHard_Nation]

Re: This Player or That Player?

I was rolling with Elite McFadden from day one and he was a monster. Then I brought in Elite Ricky Williams and I involve two back in my offense and Ricky Plays better. Just enough speed to take it to the house and get to edge. Almost always breaks the first tackle and ALWAYS falls forward.

[eurojjj19]

Re: This Player or That Player?

How does jamaal Charles compare to the elite Mcfadden?

[t3chnetic]

Re: This Player or That Player?

Give 92 Jamaal Charles a try. He's been better than most the high rated backs I've used and he's cheap.

[ivenovember]

Re: This Player or That Player?

I've been very happy with my Heisman Archie Griffin but haven't tried most of the other HBs listed here. Archie is very fast and breaks through tackles pretty well.

[kiz5]

Re: This Player or That Player?

I've been very happy with my Heisman Archie Griffin but haven't tried most of the other HBs listed here. Archie is very fast and breaks through tackles pretty well.

But terrible stamina.

[BobjumpA]

Re: This Player or That Player?

Mario Williams or Award Reggie White

[miz468]

Re: This Player or That Player?

Mario Williams or Award Reggie White

Mario Williams plays great for me, and I haven't played with Reggie White, but I imagine The Minister of Defense is the better choice here.

[eurojjj19]

Re: This Player or That Player?

What about Bettis vs Eddie George?

btw, stallworth is a very underrated wr.

[dpmx21]

Heisman Ware or Heisman RG3? Been using Ware for a while now and he's awesome. Debating on paying high for RG3 but not sure.

[BobjumpA]

Re: This Player or That Player?

What about Bettis vs Eddie George?

btw, stallworth is a very underrated wr.

Stallworth was terrible for me, he dropped half his passes.

[Go_Dawgs]

Re: This Player or That Player?

I have AP and he runs very good breaks tackles and hard to get down, I also have herchel walker who I use in short yardage situations.