Better roster - Yukon46 or OS Community???

[blues4life74]

Sorry if this has been addressed before but I was just wondering which roster is better for the 360 - Yukon's or the OS Community rosters that came out a couple days ago? I ask because I've been using Yukon's for some time now and am perfectly satisfied with his file. Is the OS Community file more accurate than Yukon's or vice versa?

[herruberraschen]

Re: Better roster - Yukon46 or OS Community???

The main difference is Yukon has made ratings adjustments to coaches and players. Both I would think try to be as accurate as possible when it comes to the "Roster." OS Community may be going deeper into equipment edits though.

[loccdogg26]

Re: Better roster - Yukon46 or OS Community???

My best advice for you would be to try them both. I use both but they are going back and making corrections on the OS one.

[Flightwhite24]

Yukons without a doubt, but at the same time I feel it would be unfair to compare the 2 right now as OS is still making tweaks/correction.

Right now the more complete set is Yukons

Sent from my SPH-L710 using Tapatalk 2

[Snake40]

Re: Better roster - Yukon46 or OS Community???

Your best option is the OS Community. Both have a ton of mistakes still, but the OS Community is the best option to work with at this time. Great thanks to all those who participated.

Snake

[ChillJ]

Re: Better roster - Yukon46 or OS Community???

I have noticed with the OS one that all the teams seem to pass way more and not run the ball. I played with Bama, Navy, GT and GT was in spread most of the game. Every first Down GT and NAVY would come out in flex then shotgun or pistol. I checked some of the coaches edits and it all leans towards pass and is different than the default settings I checked for navy towards more pass I didnt know a triple option team wanted to lean so heavy on pass and not run?

That was the old OS file which copied the coaching file from Yukon file. The new one has the coaches back to default.

[wolverinemaniac]

Re: Better roster - Yukon46 or OS Community???

Yukons without a doubt, but at the same time I feel it would be unfair to compare the 2 right now as OS is still making tweaks/correction.

Right now the more complete set is Yukons

Sent from my SPH-L710 using Tapatalk 2

I have to agree with this, I appreciate the OS guys for putting one together and continuing work. But yukons is farther along at this point and has some nice changes for people who intend on dynasty gameplay.

[vadolfan]

Re: Better roster - Yukon46 or OS Community???

are we just ignoring M&B's?

I am also interested in seeing what Fairdale Kings has to offer.

[BlackNGold]

Re: Better roster - Yukon46 or OS Community???

That was the old OS file which copied the coaching file from Yukon file. The new one has the coaches back to default.

So you're saying Yukon's coaching settings caused heavy passing? I disagree completely. I am playing a dynasty with them and have had no such issues at all.

[Clarity]

Re: Better roster - Yukon46 or OS Community???

are we just ignoring M&B's?

I am also interested in seeing what Fairdale Kings has to offer.

Second M&B's, it's well ahead of the first draft offerings curiously titled 'OS Community' (Yukon and M&B's also being community driven, insofar as they've actually *communicated* with the community.) Coach ratings tied to tSN's coach rankings, solid corrections and adjustments, accurate naming. OS Community rosters will get there, like the rest, but they're way behind and playing catch up.

All that said -- personal preference. Try them all.

[Fiddy]

Re: Better roster - Yukon46 or OS Community???

Yukon46 is a part of the OS Community.. so his have OS Community written all over it. why? bc guys like myself and others who posted in his thread helped him get his roster updated a bit.

M & B's are OS Community Rosters as well..

i wish the mods would change the name of the OS one posted since OS dont back an official roster.

IMO that roster being named OS Community Rosters is a slap in the face to Yukon46, Matt and BentleyA, among others. especially with the way those community guys handled themselves when people wanted an update etc. what did they get from those members? nothing but crickets!

Yukon46, Matt and BentleyA.. Kudos to you guys! classy from the start..

[vadolfan]

Re: Better roster - Yukon46 or OS Community???

from what I've read, Buffeye's rosters could be the best of the bunch. But I have no idea what the progress is with those.

[Birdman18]

Re: Better roster - Yukon46 or OS Community???

Buffeye's are always solid


At the moment, M&B's are hands down the best... The "OS" ones to be honest, aren't great.. Same roster everyone had release week

Yukons I feel, have players rated too high in some cases

[troy184]

Re: Better roster - Yukon46 or OS Community???

I been rolling with yukons for at least 2 weeks. They are solid.

[loccdogg26]

Re: Better roster - Yukon46 or OS Community???

from what I've read, Buffeye's rosters could be the best of the bunch. But I have no idea what the progress is with those.

Buffeye's are always solid


At the moment, M&B's are hands down the best... The "OS" ones to be honest, aren't great.. Same roster everyone had release week

Yukons I feel, have players rated too high in some cases

I was PM'd by the Buffeye staff to see if I would be able to contribute. At that time they were on the "N" s but that was a few days ago. I haven't heard anything since.