I guess the way I view is if i'm up and have 3 timeouts to spare why not try it. I iced a kicker 3 times while up by three with 2 seconds left and he still nailed a 45 yarder. Went to double OT, I missed the 2 point conversion and they came back and pulled off a 20 yard run to get to the 5. THEN they pitched to their HB and my safety cleaned him up and he fumbles! My corner (King Holder, beast on the game) recovers and we win.
BTW this was in my dynasty, i was san diego state and i was playing UCLA.