QB Vick (most obvious choice available)
QB Ben Roethlisberger
RB Ahman Green
RB Ricky Williams
RB Marshawn Lynch
RB Mikel Leshoure
RB Mike Goodson
RB Chris Rainey
RB Knowshon Moreno
RB Ronnie Brown
WR Donte Stallworth
WR Santonio Holmes
WR Kenny Britt
WR Dez Bryant
WR Justin Blackmon
WR Hines Ward
WR Brandon Marshall
WR Steve Smith
WR Terry Glenn
TE Daniel Graham
G Samson Satele
DT Josh Price Brent
DT Nick Fairley
DT Randy Starks
DE Elvis Dumerville
DE Jerry Hughes
DE Robert Quinn
DE Sergio Kindle
DE Leonard Little (I think it is bizzare they'd add him as an Elite)
DE Terrell Suggs
MLB Ray Lewis
MLB Vontaze Burfict
MLB Rolando McClain
MLB Rey Maualuga
LB Ahmad Brooks
LB Aldon Smith
LB Ronnell Lewis
CB Pac Man Jones
CB Tyrann Mathieu
CB Aaron Berry
CB Aqib Talib
CB Perish Cox
CB Charles Woodson
DB Robert Sands
S William Moore
S Brandon Meriweather
S Donte Whitner
K Sebastian Janikowski
That's a start, but there has to be more I'm missing. Thought about Randy Moss at WR, but I don't recall him breaking the law. He's just a bad teammate, but not bad enough to make the team.
Who else?
EDIT: Here's a list I came up with from this site...
http://www.utsandiego.com/nfl/arrest...e=&CPIorderBy=
Some guys are less guilty than others and I'll trim it down. I'd like a good mix of Gold, Silver and Bronze and no need for an Elite team. Just mostly a low-buget, high crime group to see if it could get on the EA Challenge.