While I appreciate your argument, I do not agree. And that is ok. How boring would the world be if we all agreed anyway!
As an adult who now works a 60-70 hour work week supporting a family, I can honestly say that working is much easier than the job I had as a collegiate athlete. Going to work and getting your butt busted in the weight room/on the field or floor are 2 different things.
Adding to this, those kids give up more than you realize from 10-18 years old. I will always remember dedicating my entire summer to AAU ball and being in the gym all day when I wasn't traveling. My buddies were all at the pool/partying and whatnot and I was obviously wanting to do that, but didn't have that option....if I wanted to attend college that is.
I have many times seen the argument "Not everyone can play college ball". This is true! So my rebuttal is to talk to a collegiate manager who works with a team! Those guys see the life college athletes live first hand. I have yet to meet one who disagrees with the notion of paying players.