ncaa draft classes vs auto generated draft classes

[niftyjets]

which do you guys prefer to use? the ncaa draft classes or the madden fake draft classes?

[brent3419]

Re: ncaa draft classes vs auto generated draft classes

i use my draft classes from ncaa. i would rather see star players in my dynasty from this current ncaa season or in future seasons to see how they do as a pro, as opposed to having leon sandcastle in the draft


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - now Free

[jje1382]

Re: ncaa draft classes vs auto generated draft classes

I use to like the ncaa draft classes. But the transferring hasn't worked the greatest in the past for me so I gave up. In madden 12 when trying to get proper draft class projections it was hard. some players wouldn't declare, etc... I like the storyline stuff that comes with the gen classes. I just wish they weren't glitched. As for leon sandcastle haha..there are some pretty funny *** videos of deion actually pretending to be him so either way you could throw him in an ncaa game and just pretend he has gone back to college like he did with the ravens.

[GlennN]

Re: ncaa draft classes vs auto generated draft classes

Since there is a bug with repeating draft classes, that entirely kills the concept, this isn't really a fair question. I like the concept of the storylines and the generated draft classes, but given the bug (and the lack of replayability, since they classes will always be the same), I'll gladly take NCAA draft classes (or an option for randomly generated draft classes).

[Pandetta]

Re: ncaa draft classes vs auto generated draft classes

I don't think I could even play a franchise without real classes. My edited NCAA classes come out pretty well, and I update them through the college season, so I am pretty happy.

[silver281gt]

Re: ncaa draft classes vs auto generated draft classes

I would love to use the NCAA draft classes but I dont have ncaa 14 and I am to computer dumb to be able to get these roster you guys make and put on here for people to download.

I dont see why we cant just get them from the roster share and use them.

[JGardner3]

Re: ncaa draft classes vs auto generated draft classes

I'm using the generated ones now because well, the reality of not having that option next year seeing as NCAA is done

[beastmode2013]

Re: ncaa draft classes vs auto generated draft classes

NCAA. Madden uses the same names and pictures every other year it seems.

[NDAlum]

Re: ncaa draft classes vs auto generated draft classes

I'm using the generated ones now because well, the reality of not having that option next year seeing as NCAA is done

That doesn't make sense. If anything wouldn't you use NCAA draft classes because this is the last time you'll be able to?

It's easy for me. Do I want Teddy Bridgewater as a franchise QB or Joe Schmoe? Plus I can't stand the crazy story lines that involve old QB's or movie characters.

No thanks jeff

[shanev]

Re: ncaa draft classes vs auto generated draft classes

I am using the ncaa class for the first year to work around the glitch. Then its all storyline from there out. It is a little bit corny, but i like the personal touch. I usually try to grab the storyline guys because they have a little backstory in an otherwise fictional league

[mavfan21]

Re: ncaa draft classes vs auto generated draft classes

Madden created classes.

Too much weird stuff happens when I import, which I had to do in year one to get around the repeating draft class glitch.

The ratings are so weird on import.

[kingsofthevalley]

Re: ncaa draft classes vs auto generated draft classes

Its not really a "this one or that one" for me man. I use both. NCAA class one year, Madden generated next year, NCAA again, rinse and repeat. Its the absolute best way to get the best of both worlds and add some flavor to your virtual football league. I honestly dont see why folks use one or the other because its like your limiting the complete experience.

[mavfan21]

Re: ncaa draft classes vs auto generated draft classes

Its not really a "this one or that one" for me man. I use both. NCAA class one year, Madden generated next year, NCAA again, rinse and repeat. Its the absolute best way to get the best of both worlds and add some flavor to your virtual football league. I honestly dont see why folks use one or the other because its like your limiting the complete experience.

This is what I plan to do as I go on. I have simed so far ahead in my NCAA class that I have all fake players anyway. I will do about 1 NCAA class every 4-5 years.

[NDAlum]

Re: ncaa draft classes vs auto generated draft classes

Its not really a "this one or that one" for me man. I use both. NCAA class one year, Madden generated next year, NCAA again, rinse and repeat. Its the absolute best way to get the best of both worlds and add some flavor to your virtual football league. I honestly dont see why folks use one or the other because its like your limiting the complete experience.

I personally don't like the fake players and their stories. The NCAA guys have stories for me because I can relate to then IRL

If you like the generated classes and the stories good for you and enjoy it


Sent from my iPhone 5

[mrbengal]

Re: ncaa draft classes vs auto generated draft classes

I'm just starting my CCM. I really enjoyed the draft classes last year, but I've read a lot of bad things about the attributes of the Madden classes this year (WRs and CBs with very bad speed/acceleration, no hidden gems, etc.). Would I get better classes by using NCAA 14? Are the physical attribute ratings for the imported classes more realistic?