I'm sorry, but y'all are crazy. His CG cf looks like how I wish MyPlayers looked, like random humans. I mean seriously. The only thing that resembles him is his tattoo, otherwise he looks like the guy from the movie Powder with hair.
The only thing "off" which I think a LOT of you are missing is that players faces move now, they animate so if he blows out his cheeks then the facial structure will seem "chubbier."