[roadman]

Quote: Originally Posted by BigDaddyHolmes

Anyone know how many times in the past 8 yrs OS has rated madden less then a 8? How much lower have they reviewed it? I ask, because there has been some really bad releases over the last 8 years, and I can't remember many, if any, 7.5 and under scores. EDIT:Found the reviews on this game from OS Madden 25 PS5/XB1-8 Madden 25-7.5 Madden 13-8.5 Madden 12-7.5 Madden 11-9 Madden 10-9 Madden 09-8.5 Madden 08-7 Madden 06-5 I'm surprised Madden 25 on PS4/Xbox 1 did any better then current gen. That leads me to think it was judged off last gen madden, and not where it should be with other games this PS4 /XB1 generation. Madden 25 PS4 was really close the same thing as Madden 25 ps3 with some graphic upgrades. Take away the resolution boost, and the game was a small difference IMO. A few nice features like o-line and ball carrier running, but weren't game changing really, and graphics certainly aren't up to next gen level. Anyway, I agree with Madden 06. Madden 12 was possibly the best Madden last gen and it got a 7.5. I'd give it a 8 at best too, but a little confused how other years could best it so much. Madden 10 was a decent year if you take all the other poor years before it into consideration, but not a 9. Probably a 7, and again it was judges off poor Maddens, not a standard of what the game should be. Madden 11 at a 9 is a head scratcher. Some of the above scores are lower then I remembered, but still this game has gotten some pretty nice reviews over last gen considering how poor it was. I certainly don't see madden 25 PS4 only .5 or so less of a game then NBA 2k14, but that is just me. For me, my review scores would have been 06-5 07-5.8 08-6 09-6.3 10-7 11-6 12-7.5 (SHOWED SOME PROMISE, SPECIALLY WITH GRAPHICS, AND CAMERA WORK PRSENTATION) 13-6.5 25-6.8 25 ps4-7

Not sure I see where you are going here or your angle? Not even sure if there is a correlation between old scores with different reviews and different reviewing systems.

All reviewers scores are subjective, aren't they, including yours and mine?