I was seeing the same thing. I was getting torn up by the CPU passing game. What I did was instead of tuning the CPU down, I tuned player sliders up a bit. I have player reaction time at 45 and pass coverage at 25. I also have
Ball Hawk OFF. CPU - QBA at 30, WR catching at 40. So far it's playing nice, Manning is playing like Manning and that QB on the Jags is playing like that QB on the Jags, lol I've also noticed when no one is open guys like Russell Wilson and RGme will take off running.