I'd rather it be Pro Yakyuu. For them to make an MLB game it would be like having a nice building up to code but then deciding that you wanted a new paint color scheme and new carpeting.
If it was MLB 2K it would be like having a building that has the carpeting and paint you need but also has faulty electrical wiring, a leaky roof, dry rot, bad plumbing, cockroaches, asbestos, weak floors, mice, loud tenants, and is in a bad neighborhood.
You get my drift.