MLB 14 The Show - Top 9 Players at Each Position

[dalger21]

Re: MLB The Show 14 - Top 9 Players at Each Position

Capt Obvious moment: I think people take these ratings a bit too seriously....

[MrOldboy]

Re: MLB The Show 14 - Top 9 Players at Each Position

With how the ratings have seemed to change, lower overall it looks like, I wonder if sim stats have been altered as well as they relate to player ratings. The players seem to actually have some space between them this time.

[NYYanks26]

Re: MLB The Show 14 - Top 9 Players at Each Position

Braun is 85 overall and there is a new roster download available (from 3/24)

[eaw913]

Re: MLB The Show 14 - Top 9 Players at Each Position

A lot of these will adjust once the season starts. Very promising IMO. It looks like a players skill is based far more on overall talent than just having a 99. I guess the system they built for RTTS translated into the overall game.

Very excited.

[tylerh]

Re: MLB The Show 14 - Top 9 Players at Each Position

I love the lower overall for relief pitchers. Also that Andrelton Simmons rating makes me happy. Just wish I could see his defensive ratings.

[berenjena]

Re: MLB The Show 14 - Top 9 Players at Each Position

LOL at people hating Yankees players on their spots respectively Haha....typical.

Alex is just right where he is at. If you take suspension and injury off and go by his numbers in the last 3 years, you'll still have a very solid player and better 3rd baseman than most 3rd baseman in baseball. Alltime greats tend to do this.

[baseballphanatic]

Re: MLB The Show 14 - Top 9 Players at Each Position

ps. no way in hell Posey is better than Molina all around.. MLB the show got that one right as well. Molina is all around the best at his position. yeah Posey is a better hitter but there is more important attributes for a catcher than just being a hitter and Molina wins in all them categories over Posey.... not to mention he is a pretty good hitter and is also clutch. why do you think the Cards have so many impressive young arms that succeed so early??? it's all because of Molina... Posey can't even come close to that Molina factor. Molina is like a manager.. pitching coach and one of the best defensive catchers I ever seen... not just in baseball now.

well.....Posey did come right in as a rookie and literally changed the Giants organization completely and molded that rotation so u cant say he cant do that either. Giants have won 2 WS in Posey's 4 years and hadn't done anything since Bonds and Kent were around. I'm pretty sure there hasn't been one player that has had the impact on a club more than Posey BUT (as a Giants fan) I will say Molina is the #1 Catcher but I think most can agree that they r 1A and 1B. Would u really complain if u had either? Let's also note that Posey is 26 years old while Molina is 31.

Now as a Giants fan I would NEVER in a million year trade Posey for Molina but I am also a realistic fan of baseball and know when a player is better then the next. Molina has been in for 10 years while Posey has technically been in for 4 but his sophomore season doesn't really count thanks to Cousins.

Molina - 10 years - 2 World Series Titles
Posey - 4 years - 2 World Series Titles

[KenJones]

Re: MLB The Show 14 - Top 9 Players at Each Position

LOL at people hating Yankees players on their spots respectively Haha....typical.

Alex is just right where he is at. If you take suspension and injury off and go by his numbers in the last 3 years, you'll still have a very solid player and better 3rd baseman than most 3rd baseman in baseball. Alltime greats tend to do this.

Yeah I think both ARod and Beltran belong in the top 10, (though maybe not number 1 for Beltran). The confusing one for me is Texiera who had steadily declined in most statistically relevant categories for the three years before his last two injury riddled ones. Most projection systems have him at 1 and a half WAR or so with low OBP and mediocre power numbers at best. I feel like he shouldn't be in the top 10.

[PsychoBulk]

Re: MLB The Show 14 - Top 9 Players at Each Position

Loving the gaps between the merely good players and the elite.

And the faux outrage from people that their favourite teams players are rated too low?

Always brilliantly amusing at this time of year

[BDKiiing]

Re: MLB The Show 14 - Top 9 Players at Each Position

Gonna go ahead and be a homer: Posey is the #1 catcher. Someone at Sony needs to show their work.

No chance. All around, Yadi is the best.

[JohnnyP1119]

Re: MLB The Show 14 - Top 9 Players at Each Position

As a Yankee fan...Mark Teixeira needs to be at like an 83.

Love the ratings though and the fact that they have your rating and then an adjusted rating based on how you are doing.

I'm glad they only gave Miggy, Trout, and Kershaw 99's...those are the right 3 and no one else, and the fact that being a 90 means you are "elite" because there is a nice gap between the players.

[andrewochs615]

Re: MLB The Show 14 - Top 9 Players at Each Position

Wonder what Machado is rated? Many baseball people think he is a top 9 3rd basemen.

[TGov]

Re: MLB The Show 14 - Top 9 Players at Each Position

Is the Adjusted Overall part of Franchise as well? Or is it just for RTTS...???

Because that would solve a lot of these disagreement about the Overalls...

[Brewhaha]

Re: MLB The Show 14 - Top 9 Players at Each Position

Braun is 85 overall and there is a new roster download available (from 3/24)

That is silly.

[Curahee]

Re: MLB The Show 14 - Top 9 Players at Each Position

That is silly.

Its called grading on a PED curve.