I've used pure analog for a while now, but I'm gonna try to transition to timing this year (mostly for cosmetic purposes, since the strides often look weird with pure analog, especially guys with high leg kicks). I started using pulse pitching when it came out and I love it because it adds that little bit of realistic uncertainty in your pitches. With the meter I felt like I could pinpoint pitches with anybody, which detracted from the realism. On defense I've started throwing without the meter since it lets the player's ratings be the deciding factor in the throw's accuracy and not the user's input.