In my opinion, it's not even close. The orientation of many of the stadiums is incorrect. The shadows often jump around for one quarter to the next. The lights were missing on top of some of the support columns. Most of the games during the day take place at what seems like high noon and it stays that way through the course of the game.
It's a shame, because the lighting at times is truly fantastic. They just don't implement it right. Watch a real early start time game (Cincinnati, Baltimore, NY, etc) ; shadows creep across the field, even in September. The way it was in 25, the progressive lighting was hardly showcased.
Lighting can give the game a great feel, and the pieces seem to be in place. They just don't seem to want to refine it.