Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC South

[iNolaNightmare]

Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC South

Guess I'll have to edit Brandin Cooks myself. Sheesh.

[wordtobigbird]

Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC South

Glad to see the the "Hybrid Defense" tag. Looking forward to seeing what they changed in our playbook.

Those top players look about right to me.

[SaintBrees]

Ok seriously, how are the packers rated better than the Saints? Saints had a top 5 D&O last season and a better record. Not to mention our free agent signings. Also I don't even want to get started on how underrated brandin cooks speed is. Fasted 40 for a wr in this draft and he only has a 95. If any other rookie wr is faster than him I'm going to blow a casket. He also had the fastest 10 yard shuttle

[friscob]

Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC South

Ok seriously, how are the packers rated better than the Saints? Saints had a top 5 D&O last season and a better record. Not to mention our free agent signings. Also I don't even want to get started on how underrated brandin cooks speed is. Fasted 40 for a wr in this draft and he only has a 95. If any other rookie wr is faster than him I'm going to blow a casket. He also had the fastest 10 yard shuttle

95 is about right for his 4.33 40 time, but please don't blow a casket!

[BreakingBad2013]

Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC South

61 players, out of 16 teams are rated 90+

That means 61 players on 16 teams are on an ALL-PRO level

139 players on 16 teams are 85+

Which means 139 players are right on the cusp of being an All-pro

This is HALF of the teams

So I can safely assume there will be 122 players that are on an ALL-PRO level that's twice as many as the spots on the ALL-PRO team.

I think that to make they game better, they must create a higher gap in ratings.
Then it would create a massive difference in Peyton Manning and Andy Dalton of Manning was a 98 and Dalton was a 76, and Pryor was a 57 and Russell was a 32, and so on with all positions. Same would go for Calvin Johnson to AJ Green to Jeremy Maclin to Devin Hester to Tiquan Underwood to Brandon Banks to Limas Sweed. It would create a need to improve positions in the off season and you'll feel weakness when your best DBs are Cary Williams and Fletcher Bradley rated at a 70 and 68 overall, tagging along with Malcom Jenkins and Nate Allen at a 73 and 60 overall. As an example.

[Khanchus]

61 players, out of 16 teams are rated 90+

That means 61 players on 16 teams are on an ALL-PRO level

139 players on 16 teams are 85+

Which means 139 players are right on the cusp of being an All-pro

This is HALF of the teams

So I can safely assume there will be 122 players that are on an ALL-PRO level that's twice as many as the spots on the ALL-PRO team.

I think that to make they game better, they must create a higher gap in ratings.
Then it would create a massive difference in Peyton Manning and Andy Dalton of Manning was a 98 and Dalton was a 76, and Pryor was a 57 and Russell was a 32, and so on with all positions. Same would go for Calvin Johnson to AJ Green to Jeremy Maclin to Devin Hester to Tiquan Underwood to Brandon Banks to Limas Sweed. It would create a need to improve positions in the off season and you'll feel weakness when your best DBs are Cary Williams and Fletcher Bradley rated at a 70 and 68 overall, tagging along with Malcom Jenkins and Nate Allen at a 73 and 60 overall. As an example.

Not starting a quarrel but saintsbrees I think you have some valid points but a little to bias

And to the person saying how is Glennon overrated, all he has is a cannon... Nothing else IMO
But he was a rookie, not saying he's trash but he didn't have the best accuracy

I like your idea breaking bad...a little to drastic with the ratings but I agree with your overall concept

[BigJT1083]

Not that it's a huge deal, but why aren't the top players sorted correctly by OVR in the pictures? I'm sure that's what EA was going for, putting the highest player on the team first and then descending. For the Colts, Vontae Davis is a 92 but listed above Robert Mathis who is a 93. It bugs me so much that they can't even get a simple thing like that right. Madden is always giving me a reason not to buy, just pure laziness and sloppiness of work. I'm sure there will be plenty more examples in the coming weeks

[SiNsinNatti]

Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC South

Not that it's a huge deal, but why aren't the top players sorted correctly by OVR in the pictures? I'm sure that's what EA was going for, putting the highest player on the team first and then descending. For the Colts, Vontae Davis is a 92 but listed above Robert Mathis who is a 93. It bugs me so much that they can't even get a simple thing like that right. Madden is always giving me a reason not to buy, just pure laziness and sloppiness of work. I'm sure there will be plenty more examples in the coming weeks

I think it was in order of pay... I think that's a CFM screenshot i.e. CAP space information.

[iNolaNightmare]

Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC South

Ok seriously, how are the packers rated better than the Saints? Saints had a top 5 D&O last season and a better record. Not to mention our free agent signings. Also I don't even want to get started on how underrated brandin cooks speed is. Fasted 40 for a wr in this draft and he only has a 95. If any other rookie wr is faster than him I'm going to blow a casket. He also had the fastest 10 yard shuttle

His catch ratings should be in the 90s or high 80s IMO. He never drops passes. He's the reigning freaking Biletnikoff award winner. I just think they're looking at where he was drafted too much, as well as him being the fourth WR taken. But it was such a deep WR class. Cooks would have been the best WR in most classes.

[friscob]

Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC South

Plus Morgan got a 4.44 dash time, yet he is higher?

You're not going to get any consistency from them, but Cooks' 95 speed is about right. Morgan had 96 speed and 94 acc last year, they probably just carried over all his attributes b/c it would be too much work to have everything make sense

[Madwolf]

Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC South

Ugh, Kelvin Benjamin's speed is awful.

[Yeah...THAT Guy]

Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC South

Glad that QB ratings seem to be on-point for a change.

Then you see Ryan Fitzpatrick as an 80 and Mike Glennon as a 79...

And no, I'm not saying Glennon should be higher than Fitz. I'm saying neither should be remotely that high lol.

[Darth Aegis]

Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC South

Donnie Moore has given up.

I'm very disappointed that His only job is to rate players, and he can't do that correctly. Laziness.

Honestly I think this is pretty much the most accurate overall rosters we have had besides the players in the high 90's like Calvin Johnson. I'm not sticking up for him,but to say he's giving up and is lazy I think is unfair. Its what he thinks the ratings should be, just like if I was doing ratings I'm sure people would be bashing me for not putting there man crush higher, lol. What you posted isn't really constructive criticism.We all know most of the individual ratings dont really affect gameplay anyways.

[Darth Aegis]

Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC South

Then you see Ryan Fitzpatrick as an 80 and Mike Glennon as a 79...

And no, I'm not saying Glennon should be higher than Fitz. I'm saying neither should be remotely that high lol.

They both suck, seems pretty close to me, Glennon should probably be lower though, but I can live with it.

[richiehero]

Re: Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC South

MLB Akeem Dent doesnt even play for the Falcons anymore. They traded him back in April... Really EA?!