I got in a half of a play now match the other night using the fbg rated rosters and used default all-madden (with sonsart's penalty sliders) and they felt damn good but it was only a half. Didn't take any stats. I go by flow and feel more than stats. I will give these a go. I've noticed that the game feels better on all-madden. All the players seem to be smarter. In the past i preferred pro or varsity but i think it must be different with these new consoles.