FIFA 15 Available Now, Post Your Impressions Here (PS4, XB1)

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • olig23
    Rookie
    • Aug 2006
    • 73

    #421
    Re: FIFA 15 Available Now, Post Your Impressions Here (PS4, XB1)

    Overall, I am very impressed by Fifa 15.

    I play on World Class difficulty and it's refreshing to find I now how to work hard to keep a clean sheet. You really have to defend properly, which is to say not constantly pressing in your own third. If find that the things that matter in real life matter in Fifa now, more than ever.

    To quantify that I would say two important things have changed. Firstly, tactics and personnel are as important defensively as in attack, which was not the case in prior iterations. So in the last game you have players using AMF players with next to no defense in CMF and even DMF. They also wanted the "attacking" full backs with pace. I've found on this one you can approach things differently and have different results. For example, Chelsea vs Arsenal. Chelsea, playing with full backs set to defend, a DMF like, Matic with Ramires also putting good defensive work in feels much more secure. I setup Arsenal realistically with Their fullbacks set to always overlap and Arteta as the deepest mid-filder. They feel more vunerable to counter-attacks and just generally more exposed. That's accurate. In the past I could have put Cazorla next to Arteta and simply been better by virtue of him being good going forward.

    Also, I find it's harder to win the ball back. You cant just press. You need to keep in line. Especially with Centre-backs. Step up and the player will move into the space behind you. It's realistic. This also means you have to take more care with the ball when you have it. If you're, say, Arsenal and have 45% possession it's because you're trying too many low percentage passes.

    I also find pace works better. You can't just hit it over the top as much. But pace on the wings, in transition can be deadly if not defended properly. That, is realistic. I like a lot of what EA have done with this one.

    I do have some complaints though.

    1. Free Kicks are way too easy to score.

    2. Goalkeepers need a little work. Any powerful shot that flies into the top corner they just stand and watch. It's very rare for the keeper not to go for the ball. Only exceptionally powerful shots. Also, they have to many shots "go through them". Many goals do come with shots very close to the keeper. But many just don;t look right. It needs tweaking.

    3. The net does not lift off the ground on every goal!! haha. No big deal but feels like a gimmick.

    4. I don't want to be an international manger. People do not manage both club and country these days (with rare exceptions). STOP IT!. Again, no big deal but I've played half a season and why do Peru want me anyway?

    5. Clearances cause too many dangerous counter-attacks.

    Overall though, for an early iteration on this gen I'm very impressed. None of my criticisms make me want to turn off the game. And many of the changes improve things significantly.

    Comment

    • half-fast
      Rookie
      • Sep 2011
      • 857

      #422
      Re: FIFA 15 Available Now, Post Your Impressions Here (PS4, XB1)

      Originally posted by olig23
      Overall, I am very impressed by Fifa 15.
      3. The net does not lift off the ground on every goal!! haha. No big deal but feels like a gimmick.
      Yes, this is a bit frustrating, lol. Even on low or dropping shots the net will lift up considerably. Very unrealistic.
      TB Lightning | Liverpool | Panathinaikos | Toronto FC

      Comment

      • mfp
        Rookie
        • Nov 2010
        • 377

        #423
        Re: FIFA 15 Available Now, Post Your Impressions Here (PS4, XB1)

        Originally posted by olig23
        Overall, I am very impressed by Fifa 15.

        I play on World Class difficulty and it's refreshing to find I now how to work hard to keep a clean sheet. You really have to defend properly, which is to say not constantly pressing in your own third. If find that the things that matter in real life matter in Fifa now, more than ever.

        To quantify that I would say two important things have changed. Firstly, tactics and personnel are as important defensively as in attack, which was not the case in prior iterations. So in the last game you have players using AMF players with next to no defense in CMF and even DMF. They also wanted the "attacking" full backs with pace. I've found on this one you can approach things differently and have different results. For example, Chelsea vs Arsenal. Chelsea, playing with full backs set to defend, a DMF like, Matic with Ramires also putting good defensive work in feels much more secure. I setup Arsenal realistically with Their fullbacks set to always overlap and Arteta as the deepest mid-filder. They feel more vunerable to counter-attacks and just generally more exposed. That's accurate. In the past I could have put Cazorla next to Arteta and simply been better by virtue of him being good going forward.

        Also, I find it's harder to win the ball back. You cant just press. You need to keep in line. Especially with Centre-backs. Step up and the player will move into the space behind you. It's realistic. This also means you have to take more care with the ball when you have it. If you're, say, Arsenal and have 45% possession it's because you're trying too many low percentage passes.

        I also find pace works better. You can't just hit it over the top as much. But pace on the wings, in transition can be deadly if not defended properly. That, is realistic. I like a lot of what EA have done with this one.

        I do have some complaints though.

        1. Free Kicks are way too easy to score.

        2. Goalkeepers need a little work. Any powerful shot that flies into the top corner they just stand and watch. It's very rare for the keeper not to go for the ball. Only exceptionally powerful shots. Also, they have to many shots "go through them". Many goals do come with shots very close to the keeper. But many just don;t look right. It needs tweaking.

        3. The net does not lift off the ground on every goal!! haha. No big deal but feels like a gimmick.

        4. I don't want to be an international manger. People do not manage both club and country these days (with rare exceptions). STOP IT!. Again, no big deal but I've played half a season and why do Peru want me anyway?

        5. Clearances cause too many dangerous counter-attacks.

        Overall though, for an early iteration on this gen I'm very impressed. None of my criticisms make me want to turn off the game. And many of the changes improve things significantly.
        I agree with your #s 2, 4, & 5.

        I disagree with what you said about holding midfielders though - tactical discipline remains poor in FIFA so you're still stuck with holding midfielders that regularly bomb forward into the attacking third, just like past FIFAs, leaving HUGE holes for easy counter-attacks. I even use the individual instructions to tell my holding CMs to stay back and yet they still bomb forward too often. Drives me nuts.

        Comment

        • Und Lahm
          Rookie
          • Nov 2012
          • 160

          #424
          Re: FIFA 15 Available Now, Post Your Impressions Here (PS4, XB1)

          I've switched to using the 100 Pressure/100 Aggression tactic vs the CPU and it has been working quite well. My defenders are actually making some challenges by themselves...

          Comment

          • Matt10
            Hall Of Fame
            • Apr 2006
            • 16656

            #425
            Re: FIFA 15 Available Now, Post Your Impressions Here (PS4, XB1)

            Playing live CM now if anyone wants to check it out - using my sliders of course:

            <iframe src="http://www.twitch.tv/matt10l/embed" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" height="378" width="620"></iframe><a href="http://www.twitch.tv/matt10l?tt_medium=live_embed&tt_content=text_link" style="padding:2px 0px 4px; display:block; width:345px; font-weight:normal; font-size:10px;text-decoration:underline;">Watch live video from MATT10L on www.twitch.tv</a>
            Youtube - subscribe!

            Comment

            • half-fast
              Rookie
              • Sep 2011
              • 857

              #426
              Re: FIFA 15 Available Now, Post Your Impressions Here (PS4, XB1)

              Does anyone else have a problem where you cant gain any XP or fcc? I could when the game started, but now it doesnt matter what I do whether I lose or win, it doesnt show up in my activities/history and I always have the same experience/currency
              TB Lightning | Liverpool | Panathinaikos | Toronto FC

              Comment

              • yonce
                Rookie
                • Feb 2013
                • 303

                #427
                Re: FIFA 15 Available Now, Post Your Impressions Here (PS4, XB1)

                Hello,

                I would like to start a career but the teams are not updated.
                do you know when it will update ?

                Comment

                • xSubzer0x
                  Rookie
                  • Jul 2013
                  • 167

                  #428
                  Re: FIFA 15 Available Now, Post Your Impressions Here (PS4, XB1)

                  They say they came out with an update but it's supposedly still missing players.

                  Comment

                  • LionsFanNJ
                    All Star
                    • Apr 2006
                    • 9464

                    #429
                    Re: FIFA 15 Available Now, Post Your Impressions Here (PS4, XB1)

                    They actually removed more players.

                    Sent from my GT-P5210 using Tapatalk
                    HELLO BROOKYLN.
                    All Black Everything

                    Comment

                    • BL8001
                      MVP
                      • Jul 2010
                      • 1884

                      #430
                      Re: FIFA 15 Available Now, Post Your Impressions Here (PS4, XB1)

                      This game has EA-itis.

                      Your first 6-7 hours playing it you are blown away at how incredible it all is.

                      The next 8-40 hours are spent wondering why you see legacy fifa issues, missing features, broken features, suspect AI, amazing rule bending, etc.

                      You spend some of those hours looking online for answers only to see that there are few answers that work other than possibly fixing kickoff matches with slider changes...cm could work if they ever have a squad update that puts many key players back into the squad file.

                      Fut is shaky, disconnects, coins not being awarded, server issues with the web and app interfaces, etc.

                      This game overall is seriously about 70% incomplete.

                      The only parts of the game that are close to finished are the kits and the stadiums.

                      The only hope I have for this game is if they care for it like the ea ufc team and put out 47 patches that fix critical things. We will see if that happens.
                      Last edited by BL8001; 10-05-2014, 08:51 AM.
                      resident curmudgeon

                      Comment

                      • mfp
                        Rookie
                        • Nov 2010
                        • 377

                        #431
                        Re: FIFA 15 Available Now, Post Your Impressions Here (PS4, XB1)

                        Originally posted by BL8001
                        This game has EA-itis.

                        Your first 6-7 hours playing it you are blown away at how incredible it all is.

                        The next 8-40 hours are spent wondering why you see legacy fifa issues, missing features, broken features, suspect AI, amazing rule bending, etc.

                        You spend some of those hours looking online for answers only to see that there are few answers that work other than possibly fixing kickoff matches with slider changes...cm could work if they ever have a squad update that puts many key players back into the squad file.

                        Fut is shaky, disconnects, coins not being awarded, server issues with the web and app interfaces, etc.

                        This game overall is seriously about 70% incomplete.

                        The only parts of the game that are close to finished are the kits and the stadiums.

                        The only hope I have for this game is if they care for it like the ea ufc team and put out 47 patches that fix critical things. We will see if that happens.
                        Yep, pretty much.

                        Comment

                        • Krebstar
                          is looking at stats.
                          • May 2005
                          • 12904

                          #432
                          Re: FIFA 15 Available Now, Post Your Impressions Here (PS4, XB1)

                          Originally posted by BL8001
                          This game has EA-itis.

                          Your first 6-7 hours playing it you are blown away at how incredible it all is.

                          The next 8-40 hours are spent wondering why you see legacy fifa issues, missing features, broken features, suspect AI, amazing rule bending, etc.

                          You spend some of those hours looking online for answers only to see that there are few answers that work other than possibly fixing kickoff matches with slider changes...cm could work if they ever have a squad update that puts many key players back into the squad file.

                          Fut is shaky, disconnects, coins not being awarded, server issues with the web and app interfaces, etc.

                          This game overall is seriously about 70% incomplete.

                          The only parts of the game that are close to finished are the kits and the stadiums.

                          The only hope I have for this game is if they care for it like the ea ufc team and put out 47 patches that fix critical things. We will see if that happens.

                          From my memory, there is almost zero history of EA releasing patches that target gameplay for FIFA. Always other issues instead, unfortunately.

                          Comment

                          • Matt10
                            Hall Of Fame
                            • Apr 2006
                            • 16656

                            #433
                            Re: FIFA 15 Available Now, Post Your Impressions Here (PS4, XB1)

                            Originally posted by Krebstar
                            From my memory, there is almost zero history of EA releasing patches that target gameplay for FIFA. Always other issues instead, unfortunately.
                            Although if it affects Online gameplay - it could be addressed. I would say man marking as the primary form of defending would be an issue. Although not sure if online players realize that yet or not.

                            I want the tactics after that. just those two fixes would set this game back on the right course.
                            Youtube - subscribe!

                            Comment

                            • half-fast
                              Rookie
                              • Sep 2011
                              • 857

                              #434
                              Re: FIFA 15 Available Now, Post Your Impressions Here (PS4, XB1)

                              Originally posted by BL8001
                              This game has EA-itis.

                              Your first 6-7 hours playing it you are blown away at how incredible it all is.

                              The next 8-40 hours are spent wondering why you see legacy fifa issues, missing features, broken features, suspect AI, amazing rule bending, etc.

                              You spend some of those hours looking online for answers only to see that there are few answers that work other than possibly fixing kickoff matches with slider changes...cm could work if they ever have a squad update that puts many key players back into the squad file.

                              Fut is shaky, disconnects, coins not being awarded, server issues with the web and app interfaces, etc.

                              This game overall is seriously about 70% incomplete.

                              The only parts of the game that are close to finished are the kits and the stadiums.

                              The only hope I have for this game is if they care for it like the ea ufc team and put out 47 patches that fix critical things. We will see if that happens.
                              The only way I can truly enjoy the game right now, especially if I'm annoyed with it is, to be play Be a Pro. I play with the Pro cam zoomed all the way in for now, and the gameplay seems a lot better. I'm actually really enjoying it. Manager mode ............. not so much.
                              TB Lightning | Liverpool | Panathinaikos | Toronto FC

                              Comment

                              • mfp
                                Rookie
                                • Nov 2010
                                • 377

                                #435
                                Re: FIFA 15 Available Now, Post Your Impressions Here (PS4, XB1)

                                Originally posted by Krebstar
                                From my memory, there is almost zero history of EA releasing patches that target gameplay for FIFA. Always other issues instead, unfortunately.
                                Pretty sure they released a patch last year shortly after release that improved the backline defending. Could be wrong but that's my memory at least.

                                I'd be shocked if they don't patch a few things, like at least the long shot exploit that everyone is doing online.

                                They desperately need to improve the defensive AI, though I don't know how much an improvement they can make with just a patch. I'd like to also see them increase the CPU defensive aggressiveness, 'cause the amount of times I've dribbled through the CPU defense without them attempting a tackle - on Legendary - is ridiculous.

                                Tactics too need to be patched. Team sheets aren't working properly online. Keepers are glitchy in some actions. CM has bugs, as usual. Defending in general is waaaayy underpowered.

                                I'd be pretty surprised if they don't release some type of fix, though I'd be equally surprised if it makes the substantial type of improvement many of us would like to see.

                                Comment

                                Working...