FIFA 15's Tactics Are a Disappointing Mystery -
Operation Sports Forums
If you're having problems logging in or staying logged in, please clear/delete your cookies/cache.
We are monitoring and fixing issues in this thread.
Thanks for your patience.
The upgrade is complete, but you've probably noticed the forums are only showing posts up to about April 8. Posts made after that are still in the process of being moved over, and that should take another week or two. Feel free to start a new thread.
The site might feel a little slow while work continues. Engineers are staying on it through the night to get things moving faster again. Thanks for your patience.
How well does FIFA 15 represent real players and clubs?
I wanted to try to answer this question. After all, I’m a realism nerd in my sports games. I always have been. “Do AI clubs and players in FIFA 15 play like reasonable approximations of their real-life selves?”
In all seriousness, this year's tactical implementation is definitely underwhelming, disappointing, and to an extent a failure.
On the surface, team sheets sounded fantastic—the ability to customize a specific formation and tactics for every single team in the game? Brilliant. However, the actual gameplay itself has gotten in the way of the tactics being implemented by the AI when facing them.
Also, I miss the previous formation editing which allowed you to set "positioning", and attack/defend work rates. The new "Instructions" system does not seem to be nearly as in depth.
All hope does not yet seem to be lost, though. Hutton has made a little discovery which could bring the AI long ball back, and Matt10's sliders are constantly trying to also bring the variety of play back into the game.
It still seems like a shot in the dark, though. FIFA 15 with FIFA 14's custom tactics would be a heck of a game. Sadly, at this point, I'm still having more fun with FIFA 14.
I do have a spreadsheet full of updated tactics ready to unveil in the near future, though. This includes not only updating tactics for teams that have changed managers, but also tweaking all tactics to preform a little better.
Thanks for the read. I almost caved this weekend and bought Fifa but after reading this I'm glad I didn't. I'll wait for PES to come out so I can read the reviews on both games before making the purchase.
I hate to say it but the game is outright lousy tactically, so much so that I just don't see myself playing the game at all once PES releases. Every single game it's more of the same. I've tried everything slider wise to get some kind of variety, unfortunately though I just came up empty. In the end I settled on a slider set that highlights FIFA's strengths, one on one play, and those highlight reel quality moments. I was this series' biggest fan for a long time, but I'm a football fan first and foremost, and the football fan in me is appalled at what we were given this year gameplay wise.
Plain & simple, tactical variety in FIFA15 is terrible.
EA should be ashamed of themselves. Team Sheets, while good in concept, fall completely short due to the removal of core features present in '14 (man marking assignments & form workrates) and the lack of tactical settings (namely build up speed) having any effect on CPU gameplay style.
I've found some encouraging slider/tactic settings that at first glance appear to allow the CPU to play some longer more dangerous passes, but it's a shame that we've had to spend nearly 2 weeks concentrating on getting a English prem club to play a single damn long ball.
Below is a video I took last night of a CPU Soho player using a long ball to great effect. I will test more & see if it was just a rare occurrence or if it actually works.
EA Sports has never been able to implement this in any sport. They make a game that looks like the real game, but it never plays like the real game, at least not the individual players or teams. They suck at being able to replicate player tendencies and the player ratings seem to be mere window dressing used for the simulation aspect only.
The only thing I'll disagree with in this article is the lack of width. I play a 4-4-2 diamond with 4 CMs and the computer always runs down the lines against me, but if I switch to say a 4-4-2 with 2 CDMs and 2 wide midfielders they will play centrally. I play only EPL so far.
Other than that I'm upset with the loss of man marking assignments and the ability to set the positions. I used to push the starting position of my wide MFs up the pitch, now I can't. also the instructions tab for CDMs is broken, doesn't matter what you do he will run up and join the attack. and only have 1 instruction for the back 4 is weak, very very weak.
EA Sports has never been able to implement this in any sport. They make a game that looks like the real game, but it never plays like the real game, at least not the individual players or teams. They suck at being able to replicate player tendencies and the player ratings seem to be mere window dressing used for the simulation aspect only.
What's sad is that in past years, we the users at least had the ability to make the game play like the real game.
Defending and marking is just simply poor. Your CDM won't stay back if you tell him. There is no reaction to the ball or to an opposing player by the players you don't control. Players constantly jerk forward or backward at terrible times. Worst of all manual controls continue to be ignored, there is no real manual switch and headers and parries still rebound directly to the AI constantly. I really thing this game could be leaps and bounds better.
Dang it guys, I am just trying to enjoy my dog garn football game and you guys have to discuss problems that might ruin it for me.
I hope you feel horrible about what you've done.
don't let it ruin it! It's still a great game and plays well and the MM is stellar, minus a few stupid things in GTN (losing reports after a couple months, someone needs to fire their secretary). Just enjoy it!
Honestly, i cannot believe it took a lot of you this long to realize this. This isn't just a fifa problem, it's an EA sports problem. The teams just don't play like themselves. Their games are bereft of individuality. No individuality through animations, ai behavior, player accessories, etc. They all play the same and the AI plays the same. This is true in NHL, FIFA and NBA. I found it astonishing when i was playing fifa and i saw Messi do a rainbow. At that point, i just turned off the game. Its been a problem for the fifa series since it's inception and i haven't seen a willingness to address the issue. Every year, they focus on superficial issues while ignoring the core issues. Reviewers continue to give the game an undeserving score and they continue to deceive themselves thinking that they made a 'good' game.
Honestly, i cannot believe it took a lot of you this long to realize this. This isn't just a fifa problem, it's an EA sports problem. The teams just don't play like themselves. Their games are bereft of individuality. No individuality through animations, ai behavior, player accessories, etc. They all play the same and the AI plays the same. This is true in NHL, FIFA and NBA. I found it astonishing when i was playing fifa and i saw Messi do a rainbow. At that point, i just turned off the game. Its been a problem for the fifa series since it's inception and i haven't seen a willingness to address the issue. Every year, they focus on superficial issues while ignoring the core issues. Reviewers continue to give the game an undeserving score and they continue to deceive themselves thinking that they made a 'good' game.
In terms of FIFA, a lot of us know it's an issue, but this is the first time in the last four years that we haven't been able to easily fix it. Custom tactics have fixed the issue in past years.
It's not as if we all just now started to smell the roses and realize it's been an issue, while previously ignoring those telling us it was. This is the first year it's been an issue to this degree.
Comment