Are you doing your testing in CFM? Sliders play out different in Play Now. Do your testing in franchise. Test these out with the new tweaks. They drop a fair amount of passes with the catching at 45..
Naw I'm not using 75 and under formula this year. Didn't have to. They work fine by just having it on All-Madden and tweaking either way which is a relief. Got tired of keeping stuff in that 75 point range.
Yeah the games are tough on the black set but it's not impossible. I win games and so do a few of my friends who use my sliders. It's tough seeing the CPU complete that high percentage but it just seems like they hold on to the ball and take dumb sacks when the accuracy is too low. So it really boils down to which issue you are willing to tolerate. I tolerate the high completion percentage because I do force them to punt a realistic amount of times per game..