How often are you blitzing?
Try WR Catch at 99 and play with it for a game or two. QBs play smarter. To me it seems like the read the coverage better and move around in the pocket very realistically. I do Coach Mode and have yet to see the HUM controlled qb scramble. But the CPU QB will. Human Controlled QBs move up to the line of scrimmage and shuffles up into the pockets and hops until he gets tackled. Usually gains 1 yard. Never, ever does he turn upfield into lots of wide open space. I've just about talked myself into not feeling bad about occasionally controlling the QB and making him take off.
This is on All Madden.
I honestly think we should setup a series of Polls and have people vote on what they think each slider does. I think we have so many slider threads going and that's good. That's allowed plenty of testing. It's time we narrow this down, i think it's essential to fixing this game. It's the only way we can get some kind of definite answers.