That's why I don't be trying to deal with the headache of getting into the penalty sliders and all that other mess. It just gets TOO complicated and I start getting frustrated. For me personally the only real issues I have with the sliders is the CPUs high completion percentage, and the USER being able to run up the middle too easy. If EA can tighten up the USER pass defense and CPUs blockshedding against the run up the middle(they bust through easy against the pass) the gameplay will be almost perfect for me. I just about got everything else playing the way I want it too..
But I'm still interested to see what you come up with. I like how you be digging deep into the gameplay. It's real helpful for me sometimes when I'm trying to adjust certain areas with my sliders.