Which PG to buy - Ruby Payton or Ruby Magic?

[timeghoul]

Who do you guys think is better? I also have Sapphire Oscar, I could just keep using him as well I guess.

[timeghoul]

Re: Which PG to buy - Ruby Payton or Ruby Magic?

Ended up just going with Magic. Payton's defense is so ridiculous though.

[Rockersdash]

Re: Which PG to buy - Ruby Payton or Ruby Magic?

Nice.

I'm going to wait until the end of these packs to buy them though, probably can finish them all with only 250K MT lol.

[Lucretius8]

Re: Which PG to buy - Ruby Payton or Ruby Magic?

Nice.

I'm going to wait until the end of these packs to buy them though, probably can finish them all with only 250K MT lol.

I'll probably do the same, but not sure if sapphire stock is even gonna be worth it.

[Phanatic21]

Re: Which PG to buy - Ruby Payton or Ruby Magic?

Stockton is @$$ in 2k every year.

[rafazaho]

Re: Which PG to buy - Ruby Payton or Ruby Magic?

In my opinion, Magic Johnson 86-87 is the best PG in the game. And Onix Oscar Robertson is the best bank to replace Magic in position 1. So much so that both are on my team. I've tried all players this position and these two are offensively and devensivamente the best. Worth every penny invested.

[QNo]

Re: Which PG to buy - Ruby Payton or Ruby Magic?

In my opinion, Magic Johnson 86-87 is the best PG in the game. And Onix Oscar Robertson is the best bank to replace Magic in position 1. So much so that both are on my team. I've tried all players this position and these two are offensively and devensivamente the best. Worth every penny invested.

If you've tried all PGs, would you mind sharing your opinion on some of the lower-rated ones? E.g. sapphire wall/lillard, CP3? Thanks.

[jbandy10]

Re: Which PG to buy - Ruby Payton or Ruby Magic?

To me, they both have strengths. It depends on what kind of lineup you run and who you are playing.

Magic's biggest weakness is his 3 pointer, but that may not be a deal breaker for you.

I am keeping both on my team and benching one depending on matchup.

If the guy is running Lebron or any PG over 6'4, then you should run Magic. But if he has Chris Paul or Diamond Lillard, I believe GP is the better start.

Again. Look at how you want to use your PG. If rebounding and post offense are not important to you in a PG, Magic isn't actually all that great.

[rafazaho]

Which PG to buy - Ruby Payton or Ruby Magic?

If you've tried all PGs, would you mind sharing your opinion on some of the lower-rated ones? E.g. sapphire wall/lillard, CP3? Thanks.

Shapphire Wall, CP3 and Diamond Lillard only have an advantage in relation to the Magic 86-87 or Oscar Robertson: the 3-point shot.

Even Allen Iverson Diamond in terms of agility and speed are equivalent, but defensively, rebounds, blocks, dunks, post control, strenght, these two (Magic and Oscar) are unbeatable.

No wonder that both have 98 overwall. And with any boost attribute, the Oscar Onyx rises to 99 overwall.

Try either of the two against other PGs and feel the difference.

[QNo]

Re: Which PG to buy - Ruby Payton or Ruby Magic?

Thank you!

[vc15]

Re: Which PG to buy - Ruby Payton or Ruby Magic?

Shapphire Wall, CP3 and Diamond Lillard only have an advantage in relation to the Magic 86-87 or Oscar Robertson: the 3-point shot.

Even Allen Iverson Diamond in terms of agility and speed are equivalent, but defensively, rebounds, blocks, dunks, post control, strenght, these two (Magic and Oscar) are unbeatable.

No wonder that both have 98 overwall. And with any boost attribute, the Oscar Onyx rises to 99 overwall.

Try either of the two against other PGs and feel the difference.

Isn't Magic 97 overall?

[rafazaho]

Which PG to buy - Ruby Payton or Ruby Magic?

Isn't Magic 97 overall?

The Ruby Magic is 97 overall.
The Gold Magic 90-91 is 95 overall.
And the Gold Magic 86-87 (the best all) is 98 overall.

And differences in attributes of the latter are quite significant in relation to the first two.

During the game the differences are even more experienced, especially on defense, speed and agility among them.

[crusaderhoops10]

Re: Which PG to buy - Ruby Payton or Ruby Magic?

Can someone tell me if Ruby Magic has plays that you can run for it? He's obviously the cheapest and want to go with him but no plays would be a deal-breaker.

Thanks

[Justin7]

Re: Which PG to buy - Ruby Payton or Ruby Magic?

Personally for me, I like Payton over Magic, not as big of a Magic fan as I am Payton. Depends if you like to post up, because Magic is a beast, I played against a guy with Magic and he abused my PG (Lillard) so I had to put Wade/LBJ on Magic. But I'd take Payton still because he has somewhat of a post game just not as good obviously plus if anyone doubles any other player Payton can knock down threes.