Why was the underhand free throw animation removed?

[Trackball]

Ever since 2K14 had Rick Barry's free throw animation taken out, its absence has been a thorn in my side.

I shoot underhand free throws in real life. Why? Because they WORK.

What, was it taken out because it worked TOO well?

Here's a couple of articles for you, because I'm on a PC and as I type this, I'm under a flash flood warning. I just wanted to get this out there while it was still on my mind.

Physics Proves It: Everyone Should Shoot Granny-Style

DeAndre Jordan Should Follow George Johnson, Learn Free Throws from Rick Barry

By the way, you put Rick Barry in MyTeam this year, but not his free throw animation? What?

[Trackball]

Re: Why was the underhand free throw animation removed?

Bumping, because I still can't get a good answer to this question after over a year.

[Jrocc23]

Why was the underhand free throw animation removed?

There's no good reason I believe man. So, it's nothing for us to really say.

Same reason they remove stuff like Steve Nash's layup package and other sig animations.

I believe they should just keep building on them and stop removing them, even if the player isn't in the game anymore. Just change the name to something else, but leave the animation as a option.

[QNo]

Re: Why was the underhand free throw animation removed?

I would guess that they can't have everything they've ever done in the game as it would blow up the game size too much, maybe even slow it down. They probably remove those animations they think are largely irrelevant to the majority of the community.

[Pokes404]

Re: Why was the underhand free throw animation removed?

I would guess that they can't have everything they've ever done in the game as it would blow up the game size too much, maybe even slow it down. They probably remove those animations they think are largely irrelevant to the majority of the community.

That's my thinking. I'm guessing they have a budgeted amount of memory dedicated to animations. So if they add something, then they probably have to eliminate something. They may have felt it was better to drop an animation that not many people used in favor of something more useful.

As for shooting free throws granny-style, I'm surprised more players who are terrible at the line don't give it a try. And for really tall guys, it does make sense from a physics standpoint to lower the release point of the ball and encourage a softer arc. But for me personally, I shot free throws at a 90% rate throughout high school but can't make 6 out of 10 granny-style (the few times that I've tried it). So it's definitely not for everyone. It wasn't ever that big of a deal for me to replicate my normal shot at the line. I'm also only 6 foot tall though, so I'm already low enough to the ground as is.

[City_foxx]

Re: Why was the underhand free throw animation removed?

Rick barry freethrow> ronnie2k jumpshot. Steve nash layups> jumping jacks stand emote. I get theres only so much space but taking out dr. J's layup package so myplayers can do the robot pregame is basketball blasphemy!

[Jrocc23]

Re: Why was the underhand free throw animation removed?

I doubt space is the issue honestly. I don't know at all, but I don't think layup animation or underhand FT takes up a lot of memory at all. It's a lot of other irrelevant stuff that could have been removed. But we are on NG. I doubt memory is the issue at this point.

[QNo]

Re: Why was the underhand free throw animation removed?

As for shooting free throws granny-style, I'm surprised more players who are terrible at the line don't give it a try. And for really tall guys, it does make sense from a physics standpoint to lower the release point of the ball and encourage a softer arc. But for me personally, I shot free throws at a 90% rate throughout high school but can't make 6 out of 10 granny-style (the few times that I've tried it). So it's definitely not for everyone. It wasn't ever that big of a deal for me to replicate my normal shot at the line. I'm also only 6 foot tall though, so I'm already low enough to the ground as is.

They rather shoot 1/10 with a regular shooting form than 7/10 with the granny form. Shaq said this a number of times, that as a hip-hop kid he'd never shoot this way and I'm sure other bigs are just the same.

[HowDareI]

Re: Why was the underhand free throw animation removed?

I doubt space is the issue honestly. I don't know at all, but I don't think layup animation or underhand FT takes up a lot of memory at all. It's a lot of other irrelevant stuff that could have been removed. But we are on NG. I doubt memory is the issue at this point.

It would honestly just make the download size larger when you install the game...I'm sure I could wait an extra 5 minutes to install so I can have all the old packages lol

The old Duncan dunk packages were cool for older big men that don't do flashy dunks..Dwight and Amare...and they had more guard layups and dunks too...

Now you got guards looking like high flyers that can barely dunk and older players doing flashy layups instead of having packages where that stuff isn't in them.

[Real2KInsider]

Re: Why was the underhand free throw animation removed?

Having too many animations is simply not a good thing from a user perspective. Cycling through 1000 animations to find the right one for you is not fun. Removing the least used options or least desirable options is beneficial even though it might minimally upset one or two people.

[Trackball]

Re: Why was the underhand free throw animation removed?

Having too many animations is simply not a good thing from a user perspective. Cycling through 1000 animations to find the right one for you is not fun. Removing the least used options or least desirable options is beneficial even though it might minimally upset one or two people.

How many people use Euroleague teams and players?

I mean, REALLY?

Can't use them in MyTeam, MyLeague, or MyGM.

I'm sure THEY take up a lot more disc space than a free throw animation.

And again, you can put Rick Barry on your MyTeam this year, but his free throw animation is completely wrong. That's not sim.

[joosegoose]

Re: Why was the underhand free throw animation removed?

How many people use Euroleague teams and players?

I mean, REALLY?

Can't use them in MyTeam, MyLeague, or MyGM.

I'm sure THEY take up a lot more disc space than a free throw animation.

And again, you can put Rick Barry on your MyTeam this year, but his free throw animation is completely wrong. That's not sim.

Rashidi isn't talking about disc space. Could you imagine having 1,000 layup packages to scroll between and choose from? It's possible to reach the point of too many options.

[Jrocc23]

Re: Why was the underhand free throw animation removed?

Rashidi isn't talking about disc space. Could you imagine having 1,000 layup packages to scroll between and choose from? It's possible to reach the point of too many options.

You're right. But it's not a lot of layup packages as is. There definitely needs to be more.

[joosegoose]

Re: Why was the underhand free throw animation removed?

You're right. But it's not a lot of layup packages as is. There definitely needs to be more.

Absolutely no disagreement there. I was just trying to correct that specific misunderstanding.

[Jrocc23]

Re: Why was the underhand free throw animation removed?

Absolutely no disagreement there. I was just trying to correct that specific misunderstanding.

Yeah, I understood what he meant