Max Scherzer or Clayton Kershaw

[cnemergut]

Finally have enough stubs to get Mike Trout and one of these guys. I'm wondering which one of these 2 do you guys pitch better with? Looking at the ratings it seems that Scherzer has the higher K/9 and a slightly lower H/9. I have never pitched with Kershaw online so i have no clue about him going in but have pitched with Scherzer before and I was great with him (19SO and 1H). However, I also don't have a single LHP in my rotation so it might be nice to have one.

[Posada]

Re: Max Scherzer or Clayton Kershaw

Since Kershaw is a lefty i would take Max!

[baseballsim]

Re: Max Scherzer or Clayton Kershaw

I would saw maybe Scherzer because I haven't had much experience with Kershaw myself.

In regards to the lefty/righty thing. If you think about it, having a lefty SP is similiar to having your righty SP facing an all left-handed lineup, right?

[Socal]

Re: Max Scherzer or Clayton Kershaw

Scherzer>Kershaw.


Kershaw is a LHP and his Changeup is too fast for his unimpressive Fastball.


In RL I'll take Kershaw.

[TonyDanzaFan]

Re: Max Scherzer or Clayton Kershaw

I like kershaw, but max is a tad better after his upgrade. His k9 is what separate him for me. I've thrown two perfect games with max and while Kershaw isn't bad, I just dominate more with max.

[BlessingSpore72]

Re: Max Scherzer or Clayton Kershaw

I just picked up both of these guys and haven't pitched a whole lot with them but Max does seem like he is a little better. I firmly believe Nolan Ryan is the best pitcher in the game. He is just so dominant

[baseballsim]

Re: Max Scherzer or Clayton Kershaw

I just picked up both of these guys and haven't pitched a whole lot with them but Max does seem like he is a little better. I firmly believe Nolan Ryan is the best pitcher in the game. He is just so dominant

I wish I knew how to pitch. I'm not too good with Ryan. I probably should avoid using that curve.

[LewisCAVS]

Re: Max Scherzer or Clayton Kershaw

I've tried both and really like them. Neither of them come close to Seaver or Ryan but those two are the very top level starting pitchers and no one in the game is as good as them.

My rotation at the moment is:

Seaver
Ryan
Kershaw
Fernandez
Cueto.

I feel really confidant pitching with all of those five.