I concur tdawg....I've given up 100 yard rushing games to teams that stick to it and have been absolutely been gashed in some games. There is a definite difference though when using a great defense versus a mediocre one...as there should be.
You're right...it isn't perfect, no slider set will be and neither will this game. However, the most crucial thing this year is I am actually having fun. All Pro is playing a very realistic and challenging game this year.