Classic Stadiums

[cws]

Why is it that Sony does not do the classic stadiums correctly? Forbes is once again not the version that was used for 80 years. Shibe is incorrect.

The Polo Grounds is closest to it real life counterpart. These were not done from scratch - probably ports from PS3. The current stadiums are fantastic, but why do a mediocre job on the classics? Too bad!

[ykiki]

Re: Classic Stadiums

Does Crosley finally have the incline in the OF?

[baseballsim]

Re: Classic Stadiums

I've seen the real images of these classic ballparks but I wouldn't be able to tell what was really lacking in MLB The Show unless I took an in-depth historical study of the actual ballparks.

What exactly is missing? I do know about the incline at Crosley was missing in PS3 but I can understand why they wouldn't be able to make it function correctly in the video game.

[HypoLuxa13]

Re: Classic Stadiums

Why is it that Sony does not do the classic stadiums correctly? Forbes is once again not the version that was used for 80 years. Shibe is incorrect.

The Polo Grounds is closest to it real life counterpart. These were not done from scratch - probably ports from PS3. The current stadiums are fantastic, but why do a mediocre job on the classics? Too bad!

I'm no historian, but in regards to Forbes: th park was only open 61 years total, and it went through several renditions of expansion, adding seats, moving the fences in, etc. So I'm not sure what you mean by "the version that was used for 80 years."

It looks like the version in The Show 16 is meant to resemble the original from 1909 until 1925 when it underwent major changes.

Edit: In fact, I thought I heard one of the Devs say in one of the streams that the classic stadiums were all modeled after either their original design, or maybe the most well known design. Something like that.

[Knight165]

Re: Classic Stadiums

They are all correct to a certain year.

M.K.
Knight165

[thaSLAB]

Re: Classic Stadiums

Why is it that Sony does not do the classic stadiums correctly? Forbes is once again not the version that was used for 80 years. Shibe is incorrect.

The Polo Grounds is closest to it real life counterpart. These were not done from scratch - probably ports from PS3. The current stadiums are fantastic, but why do a mediocre job on the classics? Too bad!

We really need someone to get out to these stadiums and take some good photos... oh, wait.

And speaking of Shibe Park, you can easily tell that it's not a port from the PS3 version.

Sent from my 831C using Tapatalk

[tessl]

Re: Classic Stadiums

I see on the calendar an entire stream will be devoted to the classic stadiums. I'm strongly considering using a classic stadium in my franchise and I'm trying to figure out the dimensions.

I want a stadium which plays pitcher friendly but not ridiculously so. I'm leaning toward Shibe but it really depends on dimensions which changed in some of those classic parks.

A wise man once told me never assume anything but I'm guessing/assuming these classic stadiums will have the same graphics and lighting as the others in the show 16. According to the calendar there is an entire stream devoted to classic stadiums. We should get the answer there.

[tessl]

Re: Classic Stadiums

We really need someone to get out to these stadiums and take some good photos... oh, wait.

And speaking of Shibe Park, you can easily tell that it's not a port from the PS3 version.

Sent from my 831C using Tapatalk

Speaking of Shibe...

http://www.operationsports.com/forum...post2047930622

...although the fans on top of the roofs across the street kind of lost their view when the owner of the ballpark raised the right field wall specifically to prevent people from watching the games from the roofs so it's kind of a moot point. Still, I thought the old vs today view of those houses across the street was kind of cool to look at.

[cws]

Re: Classic Stadiums

I'm no historian, but in regards to Forbes: th park was only open 61 years total, and it went through several renditions of expansion, adding seats, moving the fences in, etc. So I'm not sure what you mean by "the version that was used for 80 years."

It looks like the version in The Show 16 is meant to resemble the original from 1909 until 1925 when it underwent major changes.

Edit: In fact, I thought I heard one of the Devs say in one of the streams that the classic stadiums were all modeled after either their original design, or maybe the most well known design. Something like that.

It is definitely not the most well known design. No Greenberg Gardens , no scoreboard and no right field stands.

[cws]

Re: Classic Stadiums

Does Crosley finally have the incline in the OF?

No, It does not.

[cws]

Re: Classic Stadiums

I've seen the real images of these classic ballparks but I wouldn't be able to tell what was really lacking in MLB The Show unless I took an in-depth historical study of the actual ballparks.

What exactly is missing? I do know about the incline at Crosley was missing in PS3 but I can understand why they wouldn't be able to make it function correctly in the video game.

Why not? They put it Minute Maid Park in Houston.

[Knight165]

Re: Classic Stadiums

Why not? They put it Minute Maid Park in Houston.

I wondered this myself.......
Perhaps the "hill" wasn't always present?


M.K.
Knight165

[Knight165]

Re: Classic Stadiums

Now I'll make you sad.....

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/qxNuJy_6yaY" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

M.K.
Knight165

[baseballsim]

Re: Classic Stadiums

Why not? They put it Minute Maid Park in Houston.

That's true but I would imagine the video game experience at Crosley probably wouldn't make too much of a difference but I may be wrong.

One thing about the Minute Maid hill was that didn't work was the the fly ball indicator disappeared once it flew over the raised portion.

[cws]

Re: Classic Stadiums

Now I'll make you sad.....

<iframe src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/qxNuJy_6yaY" allowfullscreen="" frameborder="0" height="315" width="560"></iframe>

M.K.
Knight165

I would sure like to see Ebbets in a game someday. Yes, it did make me sad. Thanks for the video.