Seriously??? Come on. The AI is inferior. The amount of options in how you want to play the game on The Show is superior. I could paint corners all day and destroy the AI on MVP 05. They could not hit me after I got super good at meter pitching.
I played MVP 05 for 5 straight years. Loved the game. And no question one of the very best ever made. But starting with MLB The Show 11 I was totally done with MVP 05.
But if you love MVP 05....keep playing it.
I am very excited for player morale, the new contract system, new scouting (20/80 scale) and I am really happy we have a trade frequency slider!!!! Huge. Upgraded financial screens. Plenty to be pumped about.