SAME with me on PS4 but this happens when im watching, and it only seems to happen when using a custom/shared playbook it takes the fun away from using custom playbooks and watching the cpu use the plays u pick.. for me its never happened when im controlling the playcalling,
but yes very very annoying i just stopped one of my games in the middle of it after my team punted on 1st down 2 times, once was on the very first play of the series after the opening kickoff.. and then later after we completed a nice lil 15 yard pass, and then next play omg look punting on first down... for now i guess ill use the default pbs or if i use my custom pb ill just call all the plays..