EA UFC 3 wishlist thread

**SUGATA** · 09-14-2016, 09:44 AM

Re: EA UFC 3 wishlist thread

Not smart idea to make discussion in one thread about DIFFERENT themes and mechanics, this is not constructive because 1) when devs wants to get Striking mechanics info they need to read the entire mixed thread and find those about striking what they want. 2) I now can not to add concepts and ideas to New Striking for discussion, so my thread becomes not a Striking mechanics compilation (all in one place about striking changes).

Unlock such threads to bring back discussion in its place.
This for example:
http://www.operationsports.com/forum...scussions.html

and others.

"EA UFC 3 whishlist" - awesome, lets talk in this one about everything.

What you need to do as a moderator is to make a Compilation walkthrough for different threads' categories, but DO NOT LOCK THEM.

**TheShizNo1** · 09-14-2016, 09:57 AM

Re: EA UFC 3 wishlist thread

I'm not sure why you guys think the devs/GC wouldn't read through a whole thread of different constructive ideas. I think this has more to do with people feeling like "their" topic is going to be overshadowed by another topic of discussion.

**SUGATA** · 09-14-2016, 10:03 AM

Re: EA UFC 3 wishlist thread

Originally posted by TheShizNo1

I'm not sure why you guys think the devs/GC wouldn't read through a whole thread of different constructive ideas. I think this has more to do with people feeling like "their" topic is going to be overshadowed by another topic of discussion.

For example several my threads which you locked were ONE theme-mechanics oriented (Striking , clinch, sway)... Ever time devs need to ask, to find or to discuss this CONCRETE mechanics he knows where to do this,...he knew, before today. Now he will need to loose his time, energy and resourses to find this different category info in ONE huge thread.
This yr decision is totally not constructive.
If you dont think so, ask devs, ask forum mebers before doing things like this.

On the other hand, as i said, to make a One thread-index (walkthough), which gather and groups a links on threads by different mechanics/categories W/O LOCKING this linked threads - will be useful and appreciated moderator's work.

**TheShizNo1** · 09-14-2016, 10:08 AM

Re: EA UFC 3 wishlist thread

Originally posted by SUGATA

For example several my threads which you locked were ONE theme-mechanics oriented (Striking , clinch, sway)... Ever time devs need to ask, to find or to discuss this CONCRETE mechanics he knows where to do this,...he knew, before today. Now he will need to loose his time, energy and resourses to find this different category info in ONE huge thread.
This yr decision is totally not constructive.
If you dont think so, ask devs, ask forum mebers before doing things like this.

On the other hand, as i said, to make a One thread-index (walkthough), which gather and groups a links on threads by different mechanics/categories W/O LOCKING this linked threads - will be useful and appreciated moderator's work.

I actually did ask before making this and other threads. The devs can use the search function if need be like any other user searching for something on these forums. There's also a wishlist thread in every other sports section; this game is not so unique that it needs to operate differently.

**SUGATA** · 09-14-2016, 10:28 AM

Re: EA UFC 3 wishlist thread

Originally posted by TheShizNo1

I actually did ask before making this and other threads. The devs can use the search function if need be like any other user searching for something on these forums. There's also a wishlist thread in every other sports section; this game is not so unique that it needs to operate differently.

I do not see an answer why you need to LOCK themed compilation threads, so block our ability to add, evolve and discuss for ex Striking in Striking thread, but not in all-in-one (wishlist) porridge thread... it is insane. One "New striking..." thread has 12 pages, could you predict how many pages will have all-in-one Wishlist thread with locked others threads, and its discussions will be interwined/mixed each other, not useful, this is terrible decision!

**TheShizNo1** · 09-14-2016, 10:48 AM

Re: EA UFC 3 wishlist thread

Well how about we try it out and if it proves too much to handle, we'll reopen the discussion. I've said all I can on the topic, you could PM Millennium and plead your case to him.

**zeric** · 09-14-2016, 12:02 PM

Re: EA UFC 3 wishlist thread

There needs to be a wishlist thread, a thread for UFC 3 standup discussion and a seprste thread for UFC 3 ground mechanics/submission discussion. There are just too many conversstions to be had for 1 thread IMO

**johnmangala** · 09-14-2016, 03:32 PM

Re: EA UFC 3 wishlist thread

TBS

360 head movement + full mobile footwork.

Collision clinch etc.

Many many, will add more as I recall some more suggestions over the months.

**Trillz** · 09-14-2016, 04:06 PM

Re: EA UFC 3 wishlist thread

Originally posted by johnmangala

TBS

360 head movement + full mobile footwork.

Collision clinch etc.

Many many, will add more as I recall some more suggestions over the months.

360 head movement + full mobile footwork.

im not sure how they will do that with the current control set up.

**Trillz** · 09-14-2016, 04:11 PM

Re: EA UFC 3 wishlist thread

Originally posted by TheShizNo1

Well how about we try it out and if it proves too much to handle, we'll reopen the discussion. I've said all I can on the topic, you could PM Millennium and plead your case to him.

so what you going to do if the convo strays off course again?? i cant see you locking your own thread.

**johnmangala** · 09-14-2016, 04:33 PM

Re: EA UFC 3 wishlist thread

Originally posted by Trillz

360 head movement + full mobile footwork.

im not sure how they will do that with the current control set up.

Yeah that's what I hearing since the beginning as to the troubles with movement and head movement since both would require the left stick. I hope something can be figured out, it's the biggest hurdle to seamless movement.

Maybe remove the second block button and make it a techinque modifier again but a different one; not necessarily for strikes but for movements etc. Maybe move the head movement modifier to the RS when combined with L2 or the other technique modifier.

So by default you would guard the head or body but apply the body modifier (or the new technique modifier) and you guard the other. Also applying the modifier and the RS allows you to use head movement and move with the left stick. Release the modifier and you can chain slips etc to TDs and other clinch opportunities etc so you can still grapple with the RS by default.

Here maybe even more pressure sensitive input would be a service. Allowing us to strike/grapple and move at the same time etc.

**fighterforjc** · 09-14-2016, 05:24 PM

Re: EA UFC 3 wishlist thread

Completely HUD-free gameplay.

**WhoDatNinja** · 09-14-2016, 07:54 PM

Re: EA UFC 3 wishlist thread

johnmangala - what do you mean by collision clinch?

I've always thought in a boxing game if 2 guys continue walking towards each other it should just auto clinch them, or if 1 person throws a punch while the other guy is walking into them from right next to them it should clinch. Is this what you mean?

**johnmangala** · 09-14-2016, 08:04 PM

Re: EA UFC 3 wishlist thread

Originally posted by WhoDatNinja

johnmangala - what do you mean by collision clinch?

I've always thought in a boxing game if 2 guys continue walking towards each other it should just auto clinch them, or if 1 person throws a punch while the other guy is walking into them from right next to them it should clinch. Is this what you mean?

More or less
Pretty much head fighting through expanding over/under. Like colliding into over/under etc; or posting through rights and framing collar ties.

Like clinching strikes.

e: I'll find some more gifs to illustrate in sec- takes a bit to compile, I'll link some Fightland Jack Slack, Lee Wylie, bjjscout, fn, mmafighting etc youtube technique analysis for reference too.

EA UFC 3 wishlist thread

Recommended Videos

EA UFC 3 wishlist thread

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment