They already tried to move for a more casual route with Showtime and cheat-perks this year and nobody loved it. I can see your point and i agree to some extent because The Show is also a business, but to me a retro arcade mode is not a good pick especially for a game with a development cycle of 7-8 months. The reason why The Show is considered one if not the best sport simulation on the market is authenticity and the hardcore sim feeling. Stick with it, improve it.
Well, we'll see.