I'm picky too, which is always my problem...I mean I spent 3 years on sliders for ncaa....not an option on madden since the series is still alive.
It's really why I have gravitated to the 'less is more' approach on madden. Try to get a stable base that won't require tweaking for every patch.
I know we got a small patch today. I'm going to install it, delete my profile and plug in what I am working on. If it still looks good, I'm rolling with it and will post it. When the patch in Feb comes out, I will do the same.