[Caulfield]

Quote: Originally Posted by BA2929

I'm the opposite. I was on the fence and leaning towards getting the game, but now I'm definitely not getting it now that Harold Reynolds is in the booth. Even if I mute him, I won't be able to get around the fact that one of the worst color commentators in all of baseball was selected to be put in the only MLB video game on the market. Guy was taken off the World Series broadcasts for a reason. He's that bad. Just a tremendously poor decision. See you guys in a few years when Harold is out and someone else is in!

Reynolds may or may not do well in the Show, but I can think of at least 20 guys that would have been far worse picks. If you have 16, then at least you have a good game that can get you through the next few years.