[Brooke2011]

The problem I see with madden player models from a anatomical standpoint is the hinge joints where the bicep meets the elbow and the hamstring meets the poplateal region behind the patella( knee cap). These areas are way to narrow causing a very unnatural looking body that is even more prevalent when the players are moving. These areas should be thicker and the transition should be slightly gradual from one Anatomical region to the next.
If madden corrected these two areas then that alone would enhance the look of the players.