Issues with Madden 2018

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • csward
    Rookie
    • May 2009
    • 15

    #1

    Issues with Madden 2018

    There are a number of substantial issues with Madden 2018 that I have encountered so far:

    - Lighting effects at night cause major frame-rate issues on PS4 Pro (the game freezes randomly during the play).

    -Suction tackles are back in the Frostbyte engine

    -Linebackers pick off too many passes/pass defense is too good

    -Weather effects are over the top, offense is god-awful and stupidly turnover prone, with no slider to adjust this setting (there used to be).

    -field effects are still not dynamic, there are canned field progression (the snow has footprints all over the field, even when you start playing.

    -Grass textures are still flat, except in cut-scenes

    -Coach animations don't usually line up with what is happening on the field and are very repetitive/dated looking.

    -Training staff is non-existent during injuries, players just lay there, why is there no animation for the training crew on the field?.

    -Injuries during games away from the ball are not acknowledged by the officiating crew, game does not tell you who was hurt, subs, ect.

    -Offsetting penalties do not exist, penalties are not enforced on the kickoff for plays during the extra point/2pt. conversion/other scenarios. In fact, during a 2pt. conversion if a penalty occurs on a interception/fumble return for a 2pt. touchdown, the game will give the other team A FULL TOUCHDOWN when the penalty is accepted (wtf, it should simply be considered a dead play, or 2 pts. for the team forcing the turnover, with penalty assessed on the kickoff).

    -Franchise mode is still a mess. Owner mode hasn't been updated in oh, 15 years? No offensive/defensive/special teams coordinators, trainers ands scouts are stupidly basic, to the point where you wonder why they still exist in the game. It is still very easy to predict who the "stars" will be in the draft. Also, the operations aspect of owner mode is so basic it's insulting. I say simply look at the NBA 2k series, which has it's own issues, but a MUCH deeper owner/coach franchise mode. Starters don't care if they're benched, off the field personality issues do not exist (they did in some old NCAA games, players could get suspended for bad grades/infractions iirc).

    If it's in the game, it's in the game??? This is just a small list of issues, there's tons more. I enjoy Madden, but this switch to the Frostbyte engine (which is notoriously hard to program for, ask the Mass Effect Andromeda team) hurt the game this year. What do you guys think?
    Last edited by csward; 09-12-2017, 09:17 AM.
  • RefundMyMadden
    Just started!
    • Sep 2017
    • 4

    #2
    Re: Issues with Madden 2018

    This game is a defective item that is covered by EA Games manufacturers Warranty. I would demand a refund.

    Comment

    • PhillyPhanatic14
      MVP
      • Jun 2015
      • 4824

      #3
      Re: Issues with Madden 2018

      Already a thread for this...



      Also... "RefundMyMadden" is clearly a trolling account and needs to quit posting everywhere. C'mon man.

      Comment

      • Find_the_Door
        Nogueira connoisseur
        • Jan 2012
        • 4051

        #4
        Re: Issues with Madden 2018

        Pass defense is too good? What game are you playing?
        Antonio Rodrigo "Minotauro" Nogueira - UFC Hall of Fame

        Comment

        • mlb61
          Rookie
          • Oct 2014
          • 423

          #5
          Re: Issues with Madden 2018

          Originally posted by Find_the_Door
          Pass defense is too good? What game are you playing?
          Mind games?

          Comment

          • Midnite2sixman
            Rookie
            • Jan 2015
            • 163

            #6
            Re: Issues with Madden 2018

            I think this might be the most broken Madden game they've ever put out. I'm not one to complain but I'm running into so many issues with this game. I play offline CFM so I know i'm in the minority as far as their demographic is concerned but man they didn't touch that mode and they actually made it worse. Why is it so hard to select all 32 teams? Its a process and its long and tedious and in 2017 I should be able to do all the same things I could in 2003. The game is very glitchy and thats off putting to me. I've been having issues with play the moments and the gameplay itself. Theres way too many INT's still and sure maybe I should get better but I dont think secondary's should pick off almost every ball thrown their way.

            The thing is is that its not just a Madden thing. The NHL series has a lot of the same issues. EA sports used to be as good as it gets with games but they've been far surpassed by 2K and MLB the Show.

            With as many complaints as Ive been seeing the last few weeks hopefully EA will actually listen to us and give us a better game in the future.

            Comment

            • ebdaal21
              Rookie
              • Sep 2013
              • 10

              #7
              Re: Issues with Madden 2018

              No training staff during injuries? Grass doesn't look real? Really???

              I'm surprised you didn't mention the lack of post game interviews in the locker room with too many 3 legged hammers walking around...
              Last edited by ebdaal21; 09-14-2017, 11:00 AM. Reason: rephrased to be nicer :-p

              Comment

              • ncbravesfan
                Banned
                • Mar 2010
                • 472

                #8
                Re: Issues with Madden 2018

                Originally posted by ebdaal21
                No training staff during injuries? Grass doesn't look real? Really???

                I'm surprised you didn't mention the lack of post game interviews in the locker room with too many 3 legged hammers walking around...

                I miss the days when the ambulance would come out on the field. But in all honesty, they need to have more info on the screen when any player gets hurt. If you're controlling the team and need to address the injury, they do but they need something like that for all injuries. Just have a box pop up showing the player, the injury and expected return. That would be helpful.

                Comment

                • Toupal
                  MVP
                  • May 2014
                  • 1296

                  #9
                  Re: Issues with Madden 2018

                  Ignoring Franchise Mode is by far the biggest issue I have.

                  Imagine if you go to see Star Wars: The Last Jedi and it was the exact same thing as Star Wars: A New Hope, but they tweaked some minor things like turning Kylo Rens' lightsaber purple.

                  People would be outraged... Just like I am with Madden 18.

                  Comment

                  • NEOPARADIGM
                    Banned
                    • Jul 2009
                    • 2788

                    #10
                    Re: Issues with Madden 2018

                    Originally posted by Toupal
                    Ignoring Franchise Mode is by far the biggest issue I have.

                    Imagine if you go to see Star Wars: The Last Jedi and it was the exact same thing as Star Wars: A New Hope, but they tweaked some minor things like turning Kylo Rens' lightsaber purple.

                    People would be outraged... Just like I am with Madden 18.
                    Do you even have this game? Getting a little tired of you popping into every thread when you haven't even played the game.

                    Comment

                    • Toupal
                      MVP
                      • May 2014
                      • 1296

                      #11
                      Re: Issues with Madden 2018

                      Originally posted by NEOPARADIGM
                      Do you even have this game? Getting a little tired of you popping into every thread when you haven't even played the game.
                      Why would I need to play the Madden 18 when the franchise mode is the exact same thing as Madden 17?

                      Comment

                      • amp87
                        Rookie
                        • Nov 2015
                        • 30

                        #12
                        Re: Issues with Madden 2018

                        '-Injuries during games away from the ball are not acknowledged by the officiating crew, game does not tell you who was hurt, subs, ect.'

                        I cant believe the way this "feature works" and was put in the game as is thinking its acceptable in 2017. You can often tell by the small details like MLB The Show takes care of.

                        Whoever was incharge of this dropped the ball big time the integration to just even have a players name run across the ticker or let you know in game who was hurt without pausing.

                        Madden (EA) will always seem like a decade behind when it comes to this stuff.

                        Comment

                        • phantomshark
                          Rookie
                          • Sep 2010
                          • 267

                          #13
                          Re: Issues with Madden 2018

                          Originally posted by Find_the_Door
                          Pass defense is too good? What game are you playing?
                          This is absolutely true. Just played a game where the 2 teams combined for 15 INTs. Don't think I've played a game yet with less than 6 combined INTs.

                          Comment

                          • Find_the_Door
                            Nogueira connoisseur
                            • Jan 2012
                            • 4051

                            #14
                            Re: Issues with Madden 2018

                            Originally posted by phantomshark
                            This is absolutely true. Just played a game where the 2 teams combined for 15 INTs. Don't think I've played a game yet with less than 6 combined INTs.
                            That's just user skill - I average less than 0.71 ints a game for myself.

                            Sorry but it's really not true and isn't an issue. If anything pass coverage needs to be ramped up further as A.i safeties are absolutely braindead.
                            Antonio Rodrigo "Minotauro" Nogueira - UFC Hall of Fame

                            Comment

                            Working...