[gr18]

Quote: Originally Posted by ripcandlestickpark

M17 has quite a few Franchise features that M16 doesn't, such as practice squads and player editing. It also introduced a lot of new player equipment (Speed Flex helmets, one armed sleeves, current cleats) and has, in the opinion of most, better commentary. One advantage that M16 has in the gameplay department, however, is that mobile CPU quarterbacks scrambled fairly often (IIRC).

This pretty much nails it. I also think in general qb AI was better in '16 and they weren't as robo getting high completion pcts off checkdowns.'18 has some of these same issues.

I really wanted to like '17 better because of the advantages but was always conflicted between the two.