I tried up to week 6 in a cfm and havent lost. There's been close games but Ive won. I had to make a decision, whats more important Realism which is All Pro, or Challenge which is All Madden... I went with Challenge so therefore AllMadden.
I'm using my All Madden set with Slow speed and default 50 penalties. I feel like on All Madden Penalties aren't fair if custom. Since putting them to 50, Penalties seem fair. Also using my auto subs. I'm happy. I prefer to be challenged and have wins be earned so had to settle on AllMadden. I will say default All Pro had very organic and a realistic feel. Like I said, id get a few challenging games but ultimately Id win..