[Devaster]

Quote: Originally Posted by Devaster

I agree with this. It has nothing to do with the replay. It has to do with the animation more than anything on sideline catches. Frustrating. Sometimes you get lucky with a challenge that actually wins though, but usually it is because the animation triggered and you weren't given the catch, or the animation didn't trigger and the opponent was given the catch.

I just had this happen. I took a video, I think, and will upload if I managed to save it. But it looked like the receiver was sliding across my screen going out of bounds with a possession catch animation. Didn't look like the receiver got both feet in bounds, but because the possession catch animation triggered it counted. I challenged and lost.

edit: Never mind. Turns out I didn't save the footage. Happens all the time though.