Just me or roster updates been a complete joke this year?

[DreamAgain]

It feels like they have barely touched the rosters this year after updating them quite often last year. And forget about actually updating tendencies or badges.. they didn't touch them at all this year.

They actually pay somebody a full time salary to work on this? What in the actual F

[coolcras7]

Re: Just me or roster updates been a complete joke this year?

It feels like they have barely touched the rosters this year after updating them quite often last year. And forget about actually updating tendencies or badges.. they didn't touch them at all this year.

They actually pay somebody a full time salary to work on this? What in the actual F

What player rating do you need changed or accessory ? Trades were updated within 24 hours or less when they happened that includes injured player coming and going.

[UnbelievablyRAW]

Re: Just me or roster updates been a complete joke this year?

What player rating do you need changed or accessory ? Trades were updated within 24 hours or less when they happened that includes injured player coming and going.

CJ Miles is shooting 7 3's a game at a 39% clip. He is 82 in 3's. For reference, Cedi Osman has the same rating as him shooting 1 3pt a game on 39%. There is no way in hell you would argue CJ and Cedi are comparable shooters

The rating system for shooting sucks *** because there is no accounting for volume. Thats why you see George Hill at a 90 open 3pt even though he only takes 3 a game (but that rating can allow you to hit open 3's a ridiculous rate at a high volume in game).

Other than that, egregious stuff like Pascal Siakam being rated slower than Valanciunas (lol) and Vanvleet having a c- grade as a perimeter defender (even though he and Lowry are both top 10 in defensive RPM for point guards). I'm pretty sure fans of every team can point to players on their roster that are overrated/underrated in some aspects

[loso_34]

Re: Just me or roster updates been a complete joke this year?

CJ Miles is shooting 7 3's a game at a 39% clip. He is 82 in 3's. For reference, Cedi Osman has the same rating as him shooting 1 3pt a game on 39%. There is no way in hell you would argue CJ and Cedi are comparable shooters

The rating system for shooting sucks *** because there is no accounting for volume. Thats why you see George Hill at a 90 open 3pt even though he only takes 3 a game (but that rating can allow you to hit open 3's a ridiculous rate at a high volume in game).

Other than that, egregious stuff like Pascal Siakam being rated slower than Valanciunas (lol) and Vanvleet having a c- grade as a perimeter defender (even though he and Lowry are both top 10 in defensive RPM for point guards). I'm pretty sure fans of every team can point to players on their roster that are overrated/underrated in some aspects

Lowry has been in the top 10 for defensive rpm for Pg for years now but ratings don’t reflect it..it took until around last December for him to get golddefensive charger lmao.

I believe Lowry is also rated 82 or 83 from 3. Him and cj should have higher ratings just based on the volume they shoot at and the efficiency. Lowry is a top 10 shooter.

He shot 42% last year on 7.8 3pt attempts. Only 5 guys in nba history shot better over a season at that volume and his ratings didn’t reflect that at launch,

[UnbelievablyRAW]

Re: Just me or roster updates been a complete joke this year?

Lowry has been in the top 10 for defensive rpm for Pg for years now but ratings don’t reflect it..it took until around last December for him to get golddefensive charger lmao.

I believe Lowry is also rated 82 or 83 from 3. Him and cj should have higher ratings just based on the volume they shoot at and the efficiency. Lowry is a top 10 shooter.

He shot 42% last year on 7.8 3pt attempts. Only 5 guys in nba history shot better over a season at that volume and his ratings didn’t reflect that at launch,

I think last year they even had Draymond at a higher 3pt rating because he shot 2 3pts a game at a higher % compared to Lowry's 7-8. Also, Valanciunas at a 71 open 3 doesn't reflect his shooting ability at all. In a 5 minute PNO game, that rating still effectively makes him a non-threat from 3 even though he has shot 57 3's up until now, and is making them at a 44% clip.

Cedi is at a 81 rating with on 62 3's made.

Both should be at a 75-77 rating because of their low volume.

[Rip4ever]

Re: Just me or roster updates been a complete joke this year?

I think last year they even had Draymond at a higher 3pt rating because he shot 2 3pts a game at a higher % compared to Lowry's 7-8. Also, Valanciunas at a 71 open 3 doesn't reflect his shooting ability at all. In a 5 minute PNO game, that rating still effectively makes him a non-threat from 3 even though he has shot 57 3's up until now, and is making them at a 44% clip.

Cedi is at a 81 rating with on 62 3's made.

Both should be at a 75-77 rating because of their low volume.

Interesting that you forgot to mention Valanciunas 3-pt shooting before this year. He had shot what four total? I can understand being reluctant to jack up the rating of someone who over a six year period shot 60 3s.

[UnbelievablyRAW]

Re: Just me or roster updates been a complete joke this year?

Interesting that you forgot to mention Valanciunas 3-pt shooting before this year. He had shot what four total? I can understand being reluctant to jack up the rating of someone who over a six year period shot 60 3s.

Because that is irrelevant to this year. Before this year Demar rarely shot 3's and they already jacked him up to a 78 in 3's (before lowering it to a 75 currently) this season because he's attempting more even though he's shooting 32% on the year. Stuff like that tells me they have a flawed formula that changes ratings but they go back and alter individual players based on public perception (another example is CP3 and Lowry having identical shooting splits from 3 but CP3 is much higher in 3pt ratings).

Since Jan 1 JV has attempted 1.3 3pts a game at 46%. People are guarding him out there now in real life, they aren't saying on the scouting report "last year he attempted zero so we should leave him open regardless of the present data from this year" because that makes no sense. The ratings reflect current play, not precedence (because players naturally get better and add to their game every year)

[Rip4ever]

Re: Just me or roster updates been a complete joke this year?

Because that is irrelevant to this year. Before this year Demar rarely shot 3's and they already jacked him up to a 78 in 3's (before lowering it to a 75 currently) this season because he's attempting more even though he's shooting 32% on the year. Stuff like that tells me they have a flawed formula that changes ratings but they go back and alter individual players based on public perception (another example is CP3 and Lowry having identical shooting splits from 3 but CP3 is much higher in 3pt ratings).

Since Jan 1 JV has attempted 1.3 3pts a game at 46%. People are guarding him out there now in real life, they aren't saying on the scouting report "last year he attempted zero so we should leave him open regardless of the present data from this year" because that makes no sense. The ratings reflect current play, not precedence (because players naturally get better and add to their game every year)

Still too small of a sample size to make big changes. They bumped him up but if you compare him to established 3pt threat from a center he still hasn't shot many.

He has shot 60

Embiid has shot 188
M. Turner( who was injured for a dozen games) has shot 133
Lopez 265
Vucevic 177
Gasol 274
Cousins 292.

See where I am going here?

[olajuwon34]

Re: Just me or roster updates been a complete joke this year?

I think the ratings and attributes for shooting are off, a player like curry because of his high shooting ratings can be very effective at hitting almost all his open or lightly contested shots, but other players who should be able to be just as effective in hitting open shots, cant because they dont have a through the roof rating like curry. Basically my problem is that they have to have someway to put curry on top of the pack, and that means he has to hit somewhat more of the shots he takes, and all the other players have to play to they're shooting ratings and attributes, which are clearly less than currys, which makes them less effective than they should be.

[jk31]

Re: Just me or roster updates been a complete joke this year?

At least they updated shooting ratings (randomly). There are so many ratings 2k didn't touch for the whole year or for some players even for several years. When a player gets a certain dunk rating, he will keep it for years!

[006AGENT]

Re: Just me or roster updates been a complete joke this year?

COMPLETE JOKE 100% CORRECT

[edaddy]

Re: Just me or roster updates been a complete joke this year?

I think the ratings and attributes for shooting are off, a player like curry because of his high shooting ratings can be very effective at hitting almost all his open or lightly contested shots, but other players who should be able to be just as effective in hitting open shots, cant because they dont have a through the roof rating like curry. Basically my problem is that they have to have someway to put curry on top of the pack, and that means he has to hit somewhat more of the shots he takes, and all the other players have to play to they're shooting ratings and attributes, which are clearly less than currys, which makes them less effective than they should be.

hmm I HAVE A QUESTION isnt Curry on top of the pack and the best pure shooter in the nba?..I assume his ratings would be through the roof much like in real life..

[olajuwon34]

Re: Just me or roster updates been a complete joke this year?

hmm I HAVE A QUESTION isnt Curry on top of the pack and the best pure shooter in the nba?..I assume his ratings would be through the roof much like in real life..

Obviously hes a good shooter, but for them to make him like so, they have to have some way for him to play like it, and theres other shooters in this game that i feel should be able to shoot more consistent but they dont because the game doesnt want to put they're ratings near steph currys. If you look at certain shooters and they're 3 point % in real life, its almost the same if not better than curry's yet they have a way less 3 point attribute than his, like i was saying not as effective as they should be.

[loso_34]

Re: Just me or roster updates been a complete joke this year?

also saw draymond green with an open 3pt rating of 77.

according to mike wang a guy shooting 30% should be rated 70.

well draymond green is shoot 29% from 3 for the year. 31.6% when wide open and 25% with a defender 4-6 feet away. i really dont get these ratings.

[Real2KInsider]

Re: Just me or roster updates been a complete joke this year?

according to mike wang a guy shooting 30% should be rated 70.

A. That's not accurate
B. Not really his department/expertise
C. Got a direct quote