Okay. But are you telling your players stuff because they do not know, or because you are reminding them what to look for and how to react? Sounds like in 2K the user has to manually tell the players how to do something, outside base AI logic, because they will not respond according to ratings alone, as opposed to reminding players.
I think from a game perspective, it should be fun. I do not know if you would be hard on a game, especially if you understand that it is just a game.