Exactly...."ewww....arcade.....no one wants to play that....." (The irony is, it really isn't a bad experience aside from the fact that WRs catch everything.)
I still think they should rebrand the current "sim" mode as "classic" mode, get rid of the "arcade" mode altogether, and then create a true "sim" mode that adds in further "sim-style" things like calibrating the game for 120 play games, adding legit pass rush, more penalties, better fatigue, etc.