To be fair, this is still in context of ratings in Madden - I am trying to point out why Brady isn't deserving of a 99 rating (unless system is being factored in)
And to be clear, I don't even think Rodgers is deserving of a 99 at this point. I think Donald is the only one I'd truly give a 99 to since I can actually point to him being at his peak right now and dominating at every level.
One side of this argument is just getting too emotional and has fan goggles on - it shows why it's so difficult to have an accurate sports games, people can't be objective. That's how you have Tom Brady being a superman with a Favre-like arm in Madden.