Operation Sports Forums - View Single Post

JoshC1977 · 07-17-2018, 04:32 PM

Ya'll can argue left and right over Brady's REAL LIFE legacy, but it is 100% completely irrelevant to Madden 19....

What IS relevant for Madden is that his THP is inflated at 96. Drop that down to about 91-92 or so (which is MORE than adequate on Madden and mid-tier for most starting QBs) and go with whatever overall that generates for him. He doesn't have a "wet noodle" arm but a 96 is essentially a prime Favre kind of rating - it makes no sense. I think the rest of his ratings are reasonable relative to how other QBs were rated.

He's an intelligent, accurate QB with an average arm and limited mobility. I'm thinking that a more reasonable THP rating would still likely allow him to achieve a 98/99 overall in franchise mode with the field general archetype (which is EXACTLY what Brady is). BUT the current THP rating would essentially allow him to also be perfect for the Strong Arm archetype...and THAT doesn't make much sense.

(Just trying to get things back on-track here....)

07-17-2018, 04:32 PM	#108
JoshC1977 All Star OVR: 5 Join Date: Dec 2010 Location: Morgantown, WV Posts: 11,561	Re: What rating are you most annoyed at? Ya'll can argue left and right over Brady's REAL LIFE legacy, but it is 100% completely irrelevant to Madden 19.... What IS relevant for Madden is that his THP is inflated at 96. Drop that down to about 91-92 or so (which is MORE than adequate on Madden and mid-tier for most starting QBs) and go with whatever overall that generates for him. He doesn't have a "wet noodle" arm but a 96 is essentially a prime Favre kind of rating - it makes no sense. I think the rest of his ratings are reasonable relative to how other QBs were rated. He's an intelligent, accurate QB with an average arm and limited mobility. I'm thinking that a more reasonable THP rating would still likely allow him to achieve a 98/99 overall in franchise mode with the field general archetype (which is EXACTLY what Brady is). BUT the current THP rating would essentially allow him to also be perfect for the Strong Arm archetype...and THAT doesn't make much sense. (Just trying to get things back on-track here....) __________________ Play the games you love, not the games you want to love.