I would say definitely give it more time and a larger sample size. Baseball stats can lie like the devil in the short term.. so give it a few days for stats to stabilize a bit.
But, that being said, once you nail that slider set, do what i did last year and disconnect from online. You don't need any more patches anyway. While everyone was complaining about hitting mine just kept playing beautifully.
Obviously this isn't practical for everyone, if they need to connect for other games,play online, or have others using the same PS4. But if you don't need online, unplugging will give you much more fun playing time with your slider set.