My bad, then. I recall a while ago that the NFL mandated they remove the ability - it was a selling point for APF 2K8 - to hit someone after the whistle, once they are out of bounds or when the QB slides.
Do you know when it was re-introduced?
Also, to be fair VC has had a similar issue with implementing real life penalties (3 shot foul & block/charge calls) into the NBA 2K series. I'm not sure why but those three fouls I mentioned in parenthesis are nearly non-existent in NBA 2K.
Official HQ of Bills Backer/Spurs Nation